Grapes
18th September 2002, 04:22 PM
I give up ...... Our European division is doing FMEA's through a program called IQ FMEA (Apis ) I have no clue how to work this thing. Does anyone have any experience with it? I mean I have tried different packages form all over the world. I see packages trying to teach me to do FMEA's. I know FMEA's .... I want to document the darn things!!!! Don't people do FMEA's anymore?
Help :confused: ready to:truce:
Geoff Cotton
19th September 2002, 04:12 AM
Of course we "still" do FMEA's, it that they have become one of those regular routine activities that we do get worked up about any more.
I've tried all sorts of off the shelf software most of which has been very unsuitable to our needs. Use Excel and keep it simple I say.
Thats my two pence worth.
rgds
Geoff
Grapes
19th September 2002, 09:50 AM
We are using Excel, and that is why we are looking for a software program. We have been burned before and want to ensure we tie up loose ends. Things like formatting reports, creating templates, and entering repititive information make me feel less like an engineer and more like a secretary. Surely someone can help
:bonk: :frust:
"Most people don't plan to fail - they fail to plan."
Atul Khandekar
19th September 2002, 01:30 PM
Take a look at FMEA Executive:
http://www.symphonytech.com/fmeams.htm
You can download a PPT demo.
Rgds,
- Atul.
Grapes
19th September 2002, 03:23 PM
You might want to do a FMEA on your marketing. I don't know too many people who would buy software that has errors (Sp?) in its presentation.
ha ha ha !
You should check your spelling. But hey, thanks for the post. Are you writing in an access database ?
Item - Marketing
Failure mode - Spelling Error
Failure Effect - Loss of Customer, Customer Skepticism
Cause - Lack of review
Recommendation - Installation of a data check, or spell check within FMEA software program.
Atul Khandekar
19th September 2002, 03:55 PM
Thanx for that FMEA on mktg. I'll take appropriate action.
I have a standalone version that uses MS Access, and also a network version on MS SQL Server.
- Atul.
TLE
23rd October 2002, 07:59 AM
I use IQ- Software too.
The point is that this software leads you - more or less- through the FMEA.
1.When you start the FMEA in the structure editor you can create the different system elements (right click: new...)
2. split the screen, on the right side you can define function / failures / charecteristics (right click: new...)
3. open failure net
connect the failures , results, causes, if you like you can assess the results in this editor
4. open the form-sheet
there you can define actions, assess them, ....
If you are familiar with the software, itīs easy to use.
We use it direct in the FMEA- Meetings and we donīt have to work on it afterwords (complete documentation including control-plan, timetable, statistics, etc.).
Al Dyer
23rd October 2002, 10:41 PM
Just a word of hopefull advice, design your own FMEA program whether it be Excel or Access. You will find that these programs are very interrangable and compatible with others.
Give me a yell if you want any help!!!!!!!!!!!
Al...:)
Grapes
9th January 2003, 05:09 PM
My first impression was that this package seems to be on a very professional level e.g. it can switch between layouts acc. QS or VDA standards. The program offers a lot of functions for viewing, analysing, editing etc. After seeing all the buttons and menus I was wondering where to start. This took several hours.
After this I was getting irritated because of not making progress. This took the rest of the day. Now I realize that I will not be able to do any further benchmarking before doing an ex(t)(p)ensive course or training to understand this package.
I have started to look elsewhere. I don't know how buddy two posts back keeps his job if he relies on IQ FMEA
TLE
13th January 2003, 08:13 AM
Hello Steve,
I keep my job because I work with FMEA and with this software.
You are right itīs not easy to use (compared with Word & Excel). Itīs more a CAQ- Software.
If you need help, send me an e-mail, and I will send you my short Powerpoint - presentation for training which explain FMEA and how to use the software.
Also the presentation is in German, it could help you to find a start.
JaySturgeon
28th January 2003, 04:57 PM
Hello Steve,
Personally I use Powerway software and it has worked out great. It too leads through the process, but if you do not have a good, solid working knowledge of how to do FMEA you'll have trouble. I mention this only because of the marketing comment made in an earlier post. The one really great thing about Powerway is that if I have a print rev. change or something minor like that, when I update my control plan it automatically updates my PFMEA and Flow Chart at the same time. Prior to Powerway I too used excel. I do have an excel program written that has similar update capabilities. If you'd like a copy of the excel file let me know.
Good Luck
:bigwave: