# Compression Spring Force measurement correlation with Supplier

R

Hello all,
I am trying to vet our internal spring force tester, as well as our supplier's unit, and determine if we have correlation. Does anyone have an opinion on the protocol to go about doing this? I'm getting internal disagreement, and would like your opinions. Any calculation tools you could share would be most appreciated as well. I work for a major Tier 1 Japanese automotive supplier, so AIAG tools use is virtually non-existant.
RW

#### Proud Liberal

##### Quite Involved in Discussions
Have you established a set height for the measurement? You'll need the customer to agree to a fixed height if you hope to correlate.

R

Yes, the customer prints give various loads at corresponding heights for each part number.

A

#### allan-M

I've read that some people use a Bland-Altman plot in these circumstances. There are differences between correlation and agreement, and they describe this in their papers. Have not used it much, but I am always on the lookout

R

Awesome treasure trove of information Miner - thank you! Now I've got some reading to do.

#### Bev D

##### Heretical Statistician
Super Moderator
Miner references the appropriate methods. Youden plots (Dorian Shainin named this the iso-plot) and Bland-altman are based on the same statistics; they just display the data in different formats. the bland-altman does give a direct calculation of the bias between two gages. The job aid Miner references is here: "MSA tools for Elsmar" The spreadsheet includes references for all methods.

remember to establish repeatability of each gage before comparing gages.

What most people gloss over is that standard correlation / regression can't be used for measurement analysis. in standard regression the 'cause' or input factor (x-axis) is taken to be a true value and the variation is all in the output Y value. so the standard deviation of interest is the variation only in the Y value (along the axis). In measurement comparisons both values are variable, so the standard deviation of interest (the measurement error) is on a vector that is perpendicular to a 45 degree line drawn thru the origin. (if there is no measurement error, the points will fall on the 45 degree 1:1 line)