Does 4.5 - Alternative RISK CONTROL apply to the Particular Standards?

#1
Section 4.5 in the General Standard 60601-1 says: "Where this standard specifies a particular RISK CONTROL measure or test method, an alternative RISK CONTROL measure or method is acceptable, provided ...."

Does this also apply to the Particular Standards? If so, where is this stated?

Thanks!
 
Elsmar Forum Sponsor

Peter Selvey

Staff member
Super Moderator
#2
Yes, it applies to particular standards.

The structure of particular standards is that they modify the general standard. It is not actually correct to read the standards separately or to consider them as two standards, rather it is the single merged version which is "legally" correct.

When I first started working in this field (35 years ago!) the test lab would prepare reports this way, using a merged version. However, the CB scheme got lazy and started publishing separate protocols. Admittedly it's a lot of work, standards have got a lot bigger, more particulars, amendments etc. Nevertheless, it can lead to errors if the standards are read and evaluated separately.
 

Tidge

Trusted Information Resource
#3
I worked on an ME device with a particular standard that (successfully) leveraged clause 4.5; although in our case the clause was specifically invoked for one small part of a collateral standard. Without going into detail: for the type of device in question there is a clause in a collateral standard (not addressed in the particular) that appears to exist because of some underlying assumption about the way all medical devices are used, but in practice does not apply to a majority of devices in a surgical theater. There is a lot of literature on the subject, our own formative testing revealed that complying with the clause was not only against established clinical practice but was interfering with task performance and generally making performing critical tasks very difficult. In other words: there was a requirement of the standard that was not really reducing any risks but was introducing (and increasing) risks.

It wasn't easy to get the NRTL to accept the alternate risk control method. An ironic element of this story is that despite us calling out that we were invoking clause 4.5, the NRTL missed it. We had to circle back to them to get them to recognize it because (a) it was the right thing to do and (b) we didn't want to risk a "last minute" test failure showing up... but it then became a nightmare to get them to accept the volumes of data (including a significant amount of user validation and published literature that defended the alternate risk control as more effective than the one in the collateral. We already had all of this in the DHF and it was all referenced within our risk files, but they all but made us repeat validation.

I was left with the impression that the NRTL took this approach with us for a mix of reasons:
  • Human factors: They were embarrassed at having missed something we called out for them on the checklist.
  • Work Experience: Despite the (now) long history of requiring risk management as the basis of 3rd edition, NRTLs have no practical experience with actually working through Risk Management. I literally had to explain what "verification of implementation" and "verification of effectiveness" meant.
  • An inherent suspicion of any ME manufacturer who can't/won't follow a standard (for any reason, or no reason)
This interaction really soured me on the NRTL, because the long-standing test lead (who used to instruct the class on 3rd edition compliance) explained in the week-long class what was necessary to support invocation of clause 4.5... and as part of the class would point to certain 'basic safety' elements of the standard as being areas where the standard didn't quite make sense and so strict compliance wasn't necessary (with explanation). I found it extremely frustrating that he'd casually accept alternate risk controls when energy was involved but in terms of usability he was worse than a novice.
 

yodon

Staff member
Super Moderator
#4
NRTLs have no practical experience with actually working through Risk Management.
Boy, does that really hit the nail on the head! And don't even get me started about NRTL's "understanding" of software under 62304! :)
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
K COPLANARITY: Composite profile tolerance on multiple surfaces- what does" lower dimensional reference frame tolerance" control? Inspection, Prints (Drawings), Testing, Sampling and Related Topics 4
P Does FDA require certification for quality system internal audit for auditor? Qualification and Validation (including 21 CFR Part 11) 1
H Does anyone has feedback on a notified body for small companies? EU Medical Device Regulations 2
E Does IVD need to integrate with hospital IT infrastructure? Medical Information Technology, Medical Software and Health Informatics 2
D What does a level 1 (PSW) PPAP actually promise? APQP and PPAP 16
R GS1 DataMatrix code does not meet GS1 Specification EU Medical Device Regulations 0
M Does the scope of ISO 9001:2015 applies to tenders, pricing and sales department of a medical devices distributor? ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 3
K Why does load cell supplier requires force verification General Measurement Device and Calibration Topics 3
M Does C=0 strictly mean 1 bad, all bad, all the time? ISO 13485:2016 - Medical Device Quality Management Systems 6
C Does a medical device active (zinc oxide) needs BPR registration in EU? Other ISO and International Standards and European Regulations 5
D Does Risk Management apply to re-labeler (MDR) EU Medical Device Regulations 1
Ed Panek Does this FDA Requirement Apply to international (not USA) distributors for USA based manufacturing companies? 21 CFR Part 820 - US FDA Quality System Regulations (QSR) 0
S Does anyone have a checklist to prepare for ISO 13485, Stage I audit? ISO 13485:2016 - Medical Device Quality Management Systems 3
S Does a refurbished product required a new UDI? US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) 3
D Change to labelling - does it require a new 510(k)? US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) 5
M What does "constantly" mean ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 13
N Does anyone use SGS for ISO 13485 / CE certification Registrars and Notified Bodies 0
G Does FDA allows remote approvals of quality documentation. Is there any specific guidance on signing any quality records remotely? Document Control Systems, Procedures, Forms and Templates 1
B Does FDA Registration QSR need to cover non-medical devices for contract repackager? US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) 1
lanley liao Does all of the suppliers need to integrated into the supplier list qualified of the company? Oil and Gas Industry Standards and Regulations 2
0 To which part of 13485 does this refer? ISO 13485:2016 - Medical Device Quality Management Systems 3
A Medical Device Contract Manufacturer - Does the CM need to register with FDA? 21 CFR Part 820 - US FDA Quality System Regulations (QSR) 3
J Records Control - Does each individual record need to be numbered? Records and Data - Quality, Legal and Other Evidence 2
lanley liao Does the customer`s trademark belong to customer-supplied property? Oil and Gas Industry Standards and Regulations 2
H How does a gas turbine work on diesel fuel? Oil and Gas Industry Standards and Regulations 12
G What does performance specification include? US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) 1
W Where does a coatings and paint company fall in IATF? IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 5
A How much does a complete biocompatibility test package cost? Other ISO and International Standards and European Regulations 1
B Does anybody know how to get older versions of Minitab to work in Windows 10? Quality Tools, Improvement and Analysis 9
M Does the ISO 9001:2015 standard require a disaster recovery plan or emergency response plan ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 16
C Does an accessory need an IFU if it use is discussed in the Parent device IFU? 21 CFR Part 820 - US FDA Quality System Regulations (QSR) 5
S How long does it take to register a product with MHRA? UK Medical Device Regulations 14
M Quality Manual - Where does Revision History Section go? Document Control Systems, Procedures, Forms and Templates 8
U Does *anyone* know a lab that will test to EN 455-4 Medical Gloves shelf life determination? EU Medical Device Regulations 1
A Brexit When does the UK responsible person need to be in place? UK Medical Device Regulations 10
M How does IEC-60601-1 apply to a non-medical device in the patient vicinity? IEC 60601 - Medical Electrical Equipment Safety Standards Series 1
N Does anyone have experience of GB/T 34986-2017? China Medical Device Regulations 1
Z Does anyone have experience with EN ISO 17664 ? IEC 62366 - Medical Device Usability Engineering 9
F Does anyone have an ESD quality/cooler talk to share? Training - Internal, External, Online and Distance Learning 4
A What does this line from MDCG 2020-3 (MDR art. 120 substantial change) mean to you? EU Medical Device Regulations 4
D Change Approval Requirements - Does every change need formal customer approval? Design and Development of Products and Processes 17
T What does AS9100 mean when it says you must establish a process to do X? AS9100, IAQG, NADCAP and Aerospace related Standards and Requirements 24
L Does a backdate form format can be changed if wrong revision is used? Document Control Systems, Procedures, Forms and Templates 8
B General Motors and Honda Alliance - What does this mean to suppliers? IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 3
C ISO 13485 :2016 - CAPA - Does every CAPA need to be checked by regulations? ISO 13485:2016 - Medical Device Quality Management Systems 9
A Does ISO 9001:2015 cover all the requirements of ISO 10012:2003? ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 6
N FDA UDI - Label vs. Labeling - Does the insert need to include UDI? Other US Medical Device Regulations 1
A Does anyone have a checklist of API Spec 650 13th Edition? Oil and Gas Industry Standards and Regulations 0
D Does Manufacture can submit CE mark application under MDD with NB for his New product after May 2020? EU Medical Device Regulations 3
A What does this sentence "this symbol shall be used in the orientation shown" mean in ISO 780:2015? Other Medical Device Related Standards 4

Similar threads

Top Bottom