Thanks dear miner
You are right. Neither of paper don't explain how calculate DF, F and P. My question is this, how they obtained this parameters (F, P and DF)?
on the other hand, in my design, all of factors should be exist in ANOVA Table and S/R main effect plot.
In you proposed way, R removed in ANOVATable. So, with your idea, which ANOVA Table I should be report? A ANOVA Table after removing R or before removing of it? a paper similar to your way (paper 3) attached here. Is it correct paper? But in another paper that similar to paper 3, different DF was reported.
moreover in another paper (paper 5) different way (3rd way to calculate F, P, DF) was reported.