How to categorize Minor, Major or Observation for Internal Audit NCR

K

KCIPOH

#1
Hello everyone,

I would like to get a more clearer picture of how to categorize a NCR as minor, major or observation for internal audit. Would appreciate if someone can lend me a hand on this:nope:
 
Elsmar Forum Sponsor

Raffy

Quite Involved in Discussions
#2
Re: How to categorize minor, major or observation for internal audit NCR?

Hi KCIPOH,:bigwave:
In our procedure, Major Nonconformance was defined as any nonconformance that could:
1. adversely affect safety as related to products, persons or property;
2 impact the usability of a product, performance of a service, or the integrity of the quality system;
3 significantly increase product cost;
4 potentially affect the ability to meet the customer’s requirements. Examples: incorrect process parameters, missing inspections or processing steps, failure to record required data, missed or out-of-tolerance calibration
5 result from failure to implement a corrective action from the previous audit.
6 Violated the ISO9001 requirements.

Minor Nonconformance was defined as any non-systemic, isolated nonconformance that does not:
1 adversely affect the usability of a product, performance of a service, or the integrity of the quality system;
2 affect any product or process output. Example: paperwork oversights, minor changes to procedures for clarification.

And Observation was defined as a statement of fact made during an audit and substantiated by objective evidence and auditor’s informational comments based on an assessment of a special process or quality system.

Hope this helps.
Best regards,
Raffy :cool:
 
K

KCIPOH

#4
Re: How to categorize minor, major or observation for internal audit NCR?

Hello Raffy,

Many thanks to your explanations as i got the picture of where am i suppose to head on during my internal audit time :yes:
 

Colin

Quite Involved in Discussions
#5
Re: How to categorize Minor, Major or Observation for Internal Audit NCR?

Hello everyone,

I would like to get a more clearer picture of how to categorize a NCR as minor, major or observation for internal audit. Would appreciate if someone can lend me a hand on this:nope:
Why do you want to categorise them major/minor? I can see the benefit of differentiating between N/C and observation not major/minor.

If you do use major and minor N/C's, what do you expect people to do different when they address them? The only thing I can see is the timescale by which they are resolved - which should always be on any corrective action anyway. By not categorising you avoid the problems of people spending longer worrying over the grade rather than the content of the N/C; you avoid auditors 'glorifying' the fact they have raised a major; you avoid 'tit for tat' grading of majors; etc.

I raise N/C's to get things changed where they need to be changed, if they are more serious we reduce the time allowed to put in place the changes.
 
#6
Re: How to categorize Minor, Major or Observation for Internal Audit NCR?

Colin asks some very important questions!

The fact is that, however an auditor may grade a non-conformity, (often simply by checking or ticking a box) it is how the issue is described that counts. It's quite normal for an auditor to 'feel' the issue warrants a particular grade, but the issue isn't described as such

My advise, for internal audit use, is not to bother. It won't make much difference to most audit findings and each auditor will be grading things differently, despite the 'rules'.
 

RoxaneB

Super Moderator
Super Moderator
#7
Re: How to categorize Minor, Major or Observation for Internal Audit NCR?

Why do you want to categorise them major/minor? I can see the benefit of differentiating between N/C and observation not major/minor.

If you do use major and minor N/C's, what do you expect people to do different when they address them? The only thing I can see is the timescale by which they are resolved - which should always be on any corrective action anyway. By not categorising you avoid the problems of people spending longer worrying over the grade rather than the content of the N/C; you avoid auditors 'glorifying' the fact they have raised a major; you avoid 'tit for tat' grading of majors; etc.

I raise N/C's to get things changed where they need to be changed, if they are more serious we reduce the time allowed to put in place the changes.
I believe we've had this discussion before but as I have donned my ISO 9001/14001 auditing hat again to help a site out - not a Corporate gal for the next few hours at least :cool: - I'm going to jump in with my thoughts.

Why differentiate? Because of the value-added approach to problem-solving.

In my production experience, we treat a "minor" with a correction. We log it. We acknowledge it. But it's a small little hiccup in the grand scheme of things. Root cause analysis is NOT required for a hiccup. We simply wish to get rid of the annoyance....I mean, nonconformance.

I guess this would be aligned with the "observation". However, observation implies "Hey, we found something, but you don't necessarily need to do anything about." And that, to be honest, is typically unacceptable within my organization. An observation says that there is some nonconformance against requirements, does it not?

A major, on the other hand, is big issue. It implies high (potential of) risk and/or loss. It is a systematic issue and we want to get rid of it for our own sanity and the health of the management system.

An Opportunity for Improvement is for those cases where requirements are conformed to, however there is the potential to improve the process/practice/results. It is optional to implement.

When we do system audits in my company, we may note "minors" on individual processes, and we inform the area before we leave of the situation. However, at each team caucus meeting - held at the end of each day - we discuss what was found and if there are multiple minors against a particular requirement (e.g., lots of documents found to be out-of-date, unapproved but used, etc.), we'll issue a major against document control.

To summarize, why classify Minor or Major?...to ensure we take a value-added approach to treating the nonconformance.

It works for us.

Whether or not it works for others....well, I did have the local ASQ chapter president ask me to speak at a meeting on our method...
 

Marc

Hunkered Down for the Duration with a Mask on...
Staff member
Admin
#8
Re: How to categorize Minor, Major or Observation for Internal Audit NCR?

I think like you do RC, but I'm an old timer and in the recent years the 'trend' has been away from the old Major and Minor distinctions. Also has come "Observations'.

Old school:

Major: The absence of, or total breakdown of a quality management system element.
Minor: A single or minor system failure or lapse in conformance.

Also see: Major Nonconformity vs. Minor Nonconformity - Definition and Differences. See howste's post 8. Technically it's a TS 16949 definition, but...:

Major nonconformity
Is one or more of the following:
• The absence or total breakdown of a system to meet an ISO/TS 16949:2002 requirement. A number of minor nonconformities against one requirement can represent a total breakdown of the system and thus be considered a major nonconformity.
• Any noncompliance that would result in the probable shipment of nonconforming product. A condition that may result in the failure or materially reduce the usability of the products or services for their intended purpose.
• A noncompliance that judgement and experience indicate is likely either to result in the failure of the quality management system or to materially reduce its ability to ensure control of processes and products.

Minor nonconformity
Is a failure to comply with ISO/TS 16949:2002 which based on judgment and experience is not likely to result in the failure of the quality management system or reduce its ability to ensure controlled processes or products. It may be one of the following:
• A failure in some part of the client's quality management system relative to ISO/TS 16949:2002.
• A single observed lapse in following one item of a company's quality management system.

Here is an *old* page: Major vs. Minor Nonconformances.

While I understand the difference between an internal audit and an external audit, I still see significant value in assigning nonconformances as Major or Minor.

As to Observations, in Internal Audits they're fine but my *personal opinion* is that Observations by registrar auditors are stretching into Consulting.
 

Ajit Basrur

Staff member
Admin
#9
Re: How to categorize Minor, Major or Observation for Internal Audit NCR?

For Internal Audits, I prefer no categorization as lot of time is wasted in difference of opinion as to why its major and not minor or why its critical and not major and so on.

With all these discussions, the core issue gets loses steam :)
 
#10
Re: How to categorize Minor, Major or Observation for Internal Audit NCR?

I'm sure, as Roxanne says, that some organizations find grading effective. I offer a word of caution, however, to others tempted or even doing such grading:

Firstly, as I posted previously, the quantitative and qualitative information in the nc report has to support the grading!

Secondly, auditors' competencies must be demonstrated in respect to grading to ensure consistency of approach.

Thirdly, management/supervision will aggressively debate 'majors' to have the auditor downgrade them to minor! This is all part of the numbers game that people see as being more important.

I can say from past experience of all of these aspects, that it is a potentially challenging task for any audit manager to keep auditors 'calibrated' on grading, such that the two facets of audit reports are congruent. IMHO - and years of experience - it's a waste of time and better to ensure the content of the nc is value added, not a simple 'grade'!
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
I Planning to categorize documents - What Document Types? Document Control Systems, Procedures, Forms and Templates 8
M IEC 62304 Software changes - Minor labeling changes on the GUI IEC 62304 - Medical Device Software Life Cycle Processes 3
M Major vs. Minor for Internal Audits? Internal Auditing 10
C Fact or fiction - Repeat minor becomes a major IATF non-conformance IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 7
Q ISO 14001:2015 accredited but import most product - CB Raised minor NC on Life Cycle Perspective ISO 14001:2015 Specific Discussions 2
G Timing allowed by IATF to close a Remote Site Minor Nonconformance IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 2
J EU ISO 13485:2016 Recertification Audit - Effect of 10 Minor Nonconformances EU Medical Device Regulations 2
Y Informational Change control process - Major vs Minor change - Active class III medical devices ISO 13485:2016 - Medical Device Quality Management Systems 12
S Minor diameter of threaded ring gage General Measurement Device and Calibration Topics 1
D Minor non-conformance for not receiving a CofC from a heat treater Manufacturing and Related Processes 10
A Where are the rules for when a repeat minor nonconformance becomes a major? IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 36
supadrai Informational Japan Minor Change Notification Application Form - Found it? Japan Medical Device Regulations 0
P Major Finding Elevation - Do I elevate this minor finding to a major one? AS9100, IAQG, NADCAP and Aerospace related Standards and Requirements 14
W Minor Audit Nonconformance Against Determining the scope of QMS IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 12
P Received a minor for not having good measureables/goals. Need help with KPIs. IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 52
P Minor Non-Conformance - Maintenance Records Not Fully Completed ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 24
M "Minor" Address Change Implications on Product Labeling Requirements Misc. Quality Assurance and Business Systems Related Topics 2
Sidney Vianna Top 10 Major and minor NC's during IATF 16949:2016 Audits IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 8
qualprod Minor non-conformance for not controlling local regulation laws? ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 20
K Notified Body - Minor Nonconformances - They have withheld all certificates General Auditing Discussions 3
T Non-addressed Minor Finding elevated to Major Finding Internal Auditing 37
B IATF 16949: Definition Major/Minor Non-conformity IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 6
T Defining Major vs. Minor Changes to Procedures ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 11
R Classification of Major & Minor Defects AQL - Acceptable Quality Level 10
Hershal Minor quake in So Cal - 17 March 2014 Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 4
M Is a New Revision Required for Minor Document Changes? Document Control Systems, Procedures, Forms and Templates 15
L Definitions for Minor & Major Nonconformances ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 15
S What constitutes Major and Minor changes in Software Software Quality Assurance 7
F Response to ISO 13485 Audit Minor Nonconformances ISO 13485:2016 - Medical Device Quality Management Systems 6
E Short Case Studies - Major/Minor Nonconformance, Observation or OK? ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 9
L Root Cause for Minor Non-conformance regarding Supplier Delegation Nonconformance and Corrective Action 5
R Audit Plan MNC (Minor Nonconformance) ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 10
M Is a Corrective Action required for each major/minor Tool Repair? Quality Manager and Management Related Issues 7
S Minor Nonconformity for Lack of Job Descriptions in ISO 9001 ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 62
M Minor/ Major Change - Japan - When you have to notify the PMDA of a change? Other Medical Device Regulations World-Wide 1
J Major NC downgraded to Minor by Registrar during Re-Visit Nonconformance and Corrective Action 7
M Definition Major vs. Minor Non Conformance Definitions Definitions, Acronyms, Abbreviations and Interpretations Listed Alphabetically 14
S Minor NC for Not Having Management Review When Scheduled Management Review Meetings and related Processes 12
S MBA Finance major & HR minor job opportunity in TQM field Career and Occupation Discussions 1
B Root Cause Analysis for Minor Non-Conformities identified in an Audit Nonconformance and Corrective Action 13
S Auditor says a Minor Nonconformance will become a Major Nonconformance General Auditing Discussions 8
A Supplier Evaluation SOP - How do I Define Major and Minor Suppliers? Supplier Quality Assurance and other Supplier Issues 14
T External Communications - Should this have been raised as a Minor Non-Conformance? Miscellaneous Environmental Standards and EMS Related Discussions 12
J Minor NC - No MSA study on Tensile Tester IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 4
N Minor Concern - Medical Device Software and Risk Management ISO 14971 - Medical Device Risk Management 2
P Trying to figure Minor ? on Female Rolled Threads Various Other Specifications, Standards, and related Requirements 1
J Minor Corrections to Documented Procedures ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 8
M ASME B1.13M Standard - Specification of a Plug Gage of Minor Diamateter Various Other Specifications, Standards, and related Requirements 3
2 Minor Document Change Control - Minor text changes to work procedures Document Control Systems, Procedures, Forms and Templates 9
M Is it necessary to classify nonconformance as minor, major, observations in an IQA? Internal Auditing 18

Similar threads

Top Bottom