How to tell the difference between 303 and 316 Stainless Steel Bar Stock?

ScottK

Not out of the crisis
Staff member
Super Moderator
#1
We've run into a situation where a supplier has sent us one in place of another. To my eye, they look the same and the material cert called it out as it was ordered. We discovered it was not what is seemed after it had already been put on the machine and the machining properties changed.

What do you folks feel is a good, easy test to tell the difference?

We are using a hydrochloric acid test, but I'd prefer something without a hazardous chemical.

Resistivity? Hardness?

thanks.
 
Elsmar Forum Sponsor
K

Kevin H

#2
Hello Discordian, a quick grade check shows: 303 has 0/0.15 % C,1% max Si, 2% max Mn, 8.0/10.0 % Ni, 17.0/19.0% Cr, 1% max Mo (which is an optional element),0.06 % max P, and 0.15/0.35% S and is annealed to 262 max Brinell Hardness.
316 has 0.03% max C, 1% max Si, 2% max Mn, 10.0/14.0 % Ni, 16.0/18.5% Cr, 2.0/3.0% Mo, <0.045% P, <0.03 % S and is annealed to 217 max Brinell Hardness.

The best way to tell the 2 apart is run a chemical analysis. Based on the above information found on the internet from 2 different sources, the least expensive/quickest way would be to run a hardness check. If you run one and got near the 217 Brinell hardness max or over it, you could identify material as suspect and run additional tests to determine the grade. A third method would be to get a sample to run a Leco C/S test - based on C & S results (primarily S) you should be able to identify as suspect - S>0.03% and OK - S< or= to 0.03%

I would not expect them to be any different in appearance.
 
R

roland_lu

#3
Machine the 2 samples

Non-chemical ways,

Maybe you can try to machine or cut them, the experienced machine operators can tell the differences, if you are sure they are either 303 or 316.

Another way is to run electric spark spectrum analysis, it is semi-quantative, you have to have the equipment.

Wayback in the university (almost 30 years ago), we were taught that experienced workers could tell the carbon difference by using the grinding wheel, and S and P have their special colors when burned. I tried then, and could not tell :eek: .
 

Wes Bucey

Quite Involved in Discussions
#4
I confirm the only true test is chemical/spectrographic analysis. Hardness test may be compromised by too many variables. I would NOT waste time trying to do this in-house (if you have to ask how, you are not qualified to do it!)

Let's put this in perspective:
  • If you are buying bar stock directly from a mill, you have a legitimate reason (based on machinability observance) to return a sample bar to mill and ask them to confirm the analysis. Every mill will do this free of charge for mill-quantity buyers.
  • If you are buying from a reputable steel distributor who only buys stock directly from mills, they will do the same thing.
  • If you are buying scavenged goods from certain kinds of resellers, you would be best served by taking a "coupon" (a 10-12 inch cutoff from a bar) to a metallurgy lab and ask them to perform an analysis. This will cost you some money (get verbal "ball park quotes" by phone first), but armed with the results, you can either proceed to manufacture parts or stop and seek financial redress from the distributor while you obtain correct bar stock from a different source (with which you will include a test analysis as part of the contract.)
 

Jen Kirley

Quality and Auditing Expert
Staff member
Admin
#5
I agree that if you want to do the test in-house, the chemical analysis is best. Otherwise, a spectrographic analysis because the two are too similar to risk spark tests and hardness.

The supplier should do the test without charge since you have reason to believe there was a mixup. I would phone them with the request at once--do not waste any more time or use up more stock if it might be the wrong stuff!

The mill should be consulted right away because the swapped stock might still be laying around, or worse, going off to another customer mistakenly.
 

ScottK

Not out of the crisis
Staff member
Super Moderator
#7
:thanx:

This is both a mill problem and an internal problem.
The mill has mixed the two on occasion and our receiving dept has lost heat ID tags.
The problem was always caught in machining because as roland_lu says "the experienced machine operators can tell the differences". But, of course, we need to catch it before it gets to the machine because we run CNC machines with bar stock feeders, 3 machines to an operator.

At any rate these are issues I was hired to help fix.

From what you're all saying the best bet is to just stick with the chemical test (which is also what the mill recommends).

Thanks for your input.
 

ScottK

Not out of the crisis
Staff member
Super Moderator
#8
Randy said:
The taste test always worked for me when I was in aviation maintenance:lmao:
Hmmm... I'm relatively new to steel machining...

could you document the training process for this so I can teach my incoming inspectors? ;)
 

Wesley Richardson

Wes R
Trusted Information Resource
#9
Portable X-ray fluorescence equipment is available that you may consider. This equipment can be purchased. If the need is infrequent, you can get a laboratory to bring the equipment to your facility and do the sorting. It provides a semi-quantitative result. With a built-in library of alloys, it should be able to provide alloy identification. Most do not work for the lighter elements such as carbon.

The disadvantages of purchase include initial cost, maintenance, training, need for reference standards, may not be able to distinguish two very close alloys, and depending upon the State, you may need to file documentation with the State radiation board. The advantages include rapid turn-around and ability to identify a wide variety of alloys.

Wes R.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
P Who can tell me the difference between TPS (Toyota Production System) and Lean? Lean in Manufacturing and Service Industries 2
K Could anyone tell me what is relation / difference in Cpk and Ppk Capability, Accuracy and Stability - Processes, Machines, etc. 4
M Informational Some things the EU MDR 2017/745 does not tell you, but you may need to know to comply with it effectively – Part 1 Medical Device and FDA Regulations and Standards News 0
G Can anyone tell me about Tooling FMEA FMEA and Control Plans 3
O Which is better - Quietly quit using a supplier or tell supplier? Supplier Quality Assurance and other Supplier Issues 11
R Can anyone tell me requirements standards for insufflator? Other Medical Device Related Standards 1
C Quick - Tell me everything you know about TS 16949! LOL IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 5
V Tell me about AS9015 Requirement for the delegation of Product Verification AS9100, IAQG, NADCAP and Aerospace related Standards and Requirements 10
M Tell me about Benchmarking Benchmarking 4
N How can you tell if Flame Retardant "kicks off" in plastic? Manufacturing and Related Processes 4
R Can anybody tell me about p & np chart? Capability, Accuracy and Stability - Processes, Machines, etc. 4
B How do I tell my boss to write neatly without offending her? Career and Occupation Discussions 8
Jim Wynne Do you have an e-reader? Tell us about it Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 16
F Can you tell me if this table is correct? Gage R&R Problems Gage R&R (GR&R) and MSA (Measurement Systems Analysis) 12
T What does the Gage R&R results tell about my Accept/Reject Decisions? Gage R&R (GR&R) and MSA (Measurement Systems Analysis) 5
C Can SEM or other methods tell if reballed Solder spheres are Leaded or RoHS Manufacturing and Related Processes 3
B Can somebody tell me about Lithium Ion Battery pack related standards Other Medical Device Related Standards 4
1 How can you tell that Sample Data represents the Population Six Sigma 23
S What to tell your Employees prior to an Audit General Auditing Discussions 21
1 How I can tell whether or not my QMS is MDD compliant EU Medical Device Regulations 4
N Score One for the Team - I had to ball up and tell the bosses Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 7
C To tell or not to tell. Internal Auditing 32
L SCAR (Supplier Corrective Acton Request) Responses - How much do you tell? Nonconformance and Corrective Action 8
H Can you tell me a suitable "tooling" for Caliper Calibration - ISO 17025 ISO 17025 related Discussions 16
A AS9100 Implementation software to tell each of us all about AS9100 requirements Training - Internal, External, Online and Distance Learning 3
S Could someone tell me what are the results of a Gage R&R & how to interpret it? Gage R&R (GR&R) and MSA (Measurement Systems Analysis) 7
Jim Wynne Another way to tell that you've got too much money Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 16
A Tell me how the APQP process is followed - What are the steps it includes APQP and PPAP 2
S Please tell me how to start doing an FMEA FMEA and Control Plans 6
K Implementing ISO 9001 - I need it all! Please tell me the bare bones! ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 27
Wes Bucey When do we tell customers and regulators we have a problem? Quality Manager and Management Related Issues 9
G AMS 2750 - Tell me what troubles, specifically, you have had with AMS 2750 Various Other Specifications, Standards, and related Requirements 4
B Tell me How to Write a Quality Manual Quality Management System (QMS) Manuals 32
K Tell me why I should no longer reference MIL STD 105E? Inspection, Prints (Drawings), Testing, Sampling and Related Topics 16
M Show us what you make or Tell us what you do! Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 58
M How do I tell my boss I'm not qualified to do Internal Audits? Internal Auditing 32
S Tell Me All About PPAP (Production Part Approval Process) APQP and PPAP 7
F Tell me about Layered Process Audits (LPA) Process Audits and Layered Process Audits 2
I Tell me about Documentation Systems Document Control Systems, Procedures, Forms and Templates 5
P Kaizen Blitz - Who can tell me how to do Kaizen Blitz? Lean in Manufacturing and Service Industries 9
C Gage R&R study definition - Results for GRR is .0005 - What does this number tell me? Gage R&R (GR&R) and MSA (Measurement Systems Analysis) 5
Marc How do you tell which car is more American? World News 0
J What is required to tell customers after Audit where nonconformances are found IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 20
J Tell me about the 18th ABBE Principle General Measurement Device and Calibration Topics 2
Marc Execs tell regulators Sarbanes-Oxley (SOX) Costs exceed Benefits World News 0
M Definition DCX - Can someone tell me what is DCX stands for? DaimlerChrysler? Definitions, Acronyms, Abbreviations and Interpretations Listed Alphabetically 4
A Can anyone tell how do we do inprocess inspection of raw materials Inspection, Prints (Drawings), Testing, Sampling and Related Topics 8
F AS 9110 Accreditation - Can anyone tell me what to expect? AS9100, IAQG, NADCAP and Aerospace related Standards and Requirements 6
B VDA 4902 - Can anyone tell me what this is? Various Other Specifications, Standards, and related Requirements 5
Marc Baseball Fan? Microsoft will tell you which parts of a game are 'exciting' Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 2

Similar threads

Top Bottom