If Super Heroes were Real would you support a Registration Act?

Superhero Registation, Pro or Con?

  • Pro Registration

    Votes: 1 25.0%
  • Anti Registration

    Votes: 3 75.0%

  • Total voters
    4

ScottK

Not out of the crisis
Leader
Super Moderator
Yes - this totally frivolous, but since I'm reading the Marvel Civil War saga, which is about a federal Superhero registration act and how the various heroes are reacting, how would you feel if superpowered heroes and villians really existed?

Would you be pro or con a law that would outlaw any superhero that did not register his identity with the government?
 
R

ralphsulser

Re: If superheroes were real would you support a registration act?

Yes - this totally frivolous, but since I'm reading the Marvel Civil War saga, which is about a federal Superhero registration act and how the various heroes are reacting, how would you feel if superpowered heroes and villians really existed?

Would you be pro or con a law that would outlaw any superhero that did not register his identity with the government?


OooKay, um...what are you smoking?;)
 
C

Craig H.

Re: If superheroes were real would you support a registration act?

I'm already registered. Certified, too.
 
Re: If superheroes were real would you support a registration act?

Who's going to MAKE Superman register if he doesn't want to register?
What about the Invisible Man?
To paraphrase the NRA Slogan: "If you outlaw superheroes, then only supervillians are left". It's just like most standards, unenforcable.
 

ScottK

Not out of the crisis
Leader
Super Moderator
Re: If superheroes were real would you support a registration act?

Who's going to MAKE Superman register if he doesn't want to register?
What about the Invisible Man?
To paraphrase the NRA Slogan: "If you outlaw superheroes, then only supervillians are left". It's just like most standards, unenforcable.


In the Marvel series the registered heroes are "hunting" the unregistered ones as government agents.
 
J

JerryStem

Re: If superheroes were real would you support a registration act?

Guess this is kinda like the X-Men series? (disclaimer - no nothing about comic books, have seen X-Men I & II movies). The issue with mutants being treated as dangerous criminals?

I don't really support registering anyone so I guess I'd be against...

Jerry
 

errhine

Involved - Posts
Re: If superheroes were real would you support a registration act?

If I were a superhero, and my superpowers were registered as being able to deceive everybody.... would I be arrested for lying on the registration?:notme:
 
L

little__cee

Re: If superheroes were real would you support a registration act?

This thread reminds me that I have to watch that new Stan Lee show.
 
W

wmarhel

I get a reserved copy of this for my son and we usually read it together. Anything to get them interested in reading.

This is pretty interesting though. Definitely realize why I was never a Spiderman fan, but Capt. America is getting two thumbs up.

Wayne
 
Top Bottom