lean kaizen: forewordKaizen started in the era of Just in Time and the Toyota Production System; it started - together with other related disciplines (such as Flow Production, One-Piece Flow, Cell Manufacturing, TPM-Total Productive Maintenance, SMED, etc.) - in the Manufacturing Industry in Japan (years '70s).
Lean Kaizen, originating in the first years 2000s, is a Lean development of "traditional" Kaizen.
"traditional" kaizenThe Japanese word kaizen means: continuous, systematic, step-by-step improvement.
the main features
the main features
The key-words are:
- Continuous: under the Kaizen angle of the view, there is no limit to improvement (...the sky is the limit....). It can carry on forever and ever, and there will always be more space for extra improvement.
- Systematic: Kaizen-style improvement must take place in a rational way - identifying areas needing improvement - prioritising areas needing to be improved - qualifying and quantifying the level of improvement needed - planning improvement actions and initiatives - implementing them in a systematic fashion - and measuring the actual improvement achieved, comparing the "before" to the "after" status.
- Step-by-step, meaning: in small, gradual, incremental steps.
Japanese made a clear distinction between kaizen and kayrio.
Kayrio means "large-size" improvement, generally "costly" (such as in the case of technological revamping) and, generally, also rather "fast".
Whereas, under the Kaizen angle of view, improvement may take time and - mostly - should be "inexpensive" or - at least - "economical" ("poor-man-approach": the poor man has no money to throw at things - but he has a "brain", capable of generating ideas and solutions.....).
In "traditional" Kaizen, Improvement means: increase in Efficiency (core parameter of Productivity) and/or Effectiveness (core parameter of Quality) in an "area" under scrutiny.
Improvement can be achieved: A) through Preventive Actions or B) Corrective Actions.
A Preventive Action is an initiative addressed to ensure that "something" will not go wrong (for instance, a Poka-Yoke device that will prevent a possible malfunction of a machine....).
A Corrective Action is an initiative targeting at eliminating some malfunction already experienced and noticed.
MAIN FEATURES OF "TRADITIONAL" KAIZEN
- Kaizen is a systematic and methodical approach to continuous improvement
- Kaizen is top-driven, co-ordinated and supported, but
- with deep, active involvement of those concerned in each improvement area (bottom-up approach)
- Kaizen target is excellence
THE PIERS OF KAIZEN
Possibly, the most important feature of "traditional" Kaizen is the bottom-up approach.
The assumption is: ".....the person doing the job knows far more than anyone else as to the best way of doing that job, and therefore is the one person best fit to improve it...".
- ".....if he/she only knew how.....!" (i.e. Technical Training is required!)
- "..and if he/she was given the opportunity.....!" (i.e. people must be empowered to act for improvement initiatives!)
In a top-driven mode, the Kaizen approach gives people at all levels, in each area needing improvement, the training, the space, the power, and the tools required to produce, working in team, creative ideas and solutions required for such improvement.
The rather famous Gemba approach summarised the main feature of the Kaizen Methodology.
With Managers from various Levels and from different Functions going on a daily basis to the Shop Floor (and not only) and meeting (formally and informally) with workers and other personnel: to discuss about the problems surfaced during the day and other ongoing problems - to launch together possible Kaizen initiatives addressed to rectify/confine/resolve those problems - to assess results - and to praise those more committed and more effective in tackling problems.
Therefore, the "piers" of effective Kaizen are: Communication and Creativity.
Communication is of paramount importance to work efficiently and effectively in team during each Kaizen session.
As it is Creativity, in order to produce - in team - valid ideas and solutions.
Certainly, Tools (see below) are very important. As it is the Kaizen Method/Approach, as well as People commitment to improvement.
But possibly the most important factor for real improvement is Brainpower!
Because of the poor-man-approach, ideas and creative solutions are the real "heart" of Kaizen!
TOOLS FOR KAIZEN
In "traditional" (and not only) Kaizen, people are well trained to use the necessary tools and available disciplines. They include (to mention the most important):
- Tools to collect/organise/classify data, to measure, to assess, such as:
Data Collection Chart, Scatter Diagram, Control Charts, Flow-Charts, Graphs, Histograms, Pareto Diagram, ABC Analysis, Radar (Spider) Charts
- Tools to solve problems, to tackle complexity, to produce creative ideas, such as:
K-T method, Critical Examination & other "global" Problem-Solvers, Brainstorming & other Creative P/S techniques, Cause and Effect (Ishikawa) Diagram, Relations Diagram, Affinity Diagram, CEDAC, Arrow Diagram, Matrix Diagrams, Poka-Yoke, Quality Circles, P-M Analysis, FMEA/FMECA Methods
- Methodologies to approach the decision-making process, such as:
Archer Method, Optimisation Methods, Elimination and Evaluation Charts, Decision Trial-Balance Method, Matrix techniques, Tree (Systematic) Diagram
"TRADITIONAL" KAIZEN - THE BENEFITS
Kaizen brought a large number of benefits to Industry - not only in Japan - where it all started, but also to the Western world (where Kaizen was subsequently adopted with some touch-ups, necessary to adapt the methodology to western culture and style......).
Two major ones, worth to mention:
- Possibly for the first time in industrial history, Kaizen introduced a systematic methodology to "query" the status quo (given practically for granted by people too busy to produce, to work, to manage, to do things.... in a routine-style) - and then to change the present situation for the better.
- Possibly for the first time in industrial history, Kaizen opened the doors to Personnel Involvement (bottom-up approach)).
Two major benefits indeed.
lean kaizen"Traditional" Kaizen came to the western world like a lightening: people in industry got fascinated by the concept of "continuous improvement", a bit less - perhaps - by its "bottom-up" approach.
the main features
the main features
Nevertheless, the went for it!
In a "westernalized" fashion, they invented the famous Suggestion Box scheme (whereby personnel at all levels would be "involved" by inserting written, most often anonymous, suggestions regarding "items" to be improved.....)
And they invented Kaizen Board Meetings (where middle/high-level managers would meet - even on a weekly frequency - to attend to items to be improved.....)
And, obviously, there was an improvements list, with all items requiring improvement....
And so on..... Surely, only few industries in the West practised Kaizen with its original "spirit" and "methodology".
I recall an old story regarding Western Kaizen:
In a "Mediterranean" Country, I was conducting training seminars followed by a day's consulting visit to participating companies premises (to give advice related to the seminar's content).
The previous year I had presented a well successful seminar on "traditional" Kaizen. This time, the same participants of the previous year - all from a company I had already visited - attended the new training seminar.
I remember very well the CEO of that Company (attending previous year and this year) telling me: "....Dr. Carlo, when you will visit us next week, you will be amazed to see how we put into practice the Kaizen messages you gave us last year!"
Very intrigued, I asked (as I always do) if I could carry my Video Camera with me.
"Of course! You are welcome!"
So, company visit's day comes, and I am welcomed at the Company premises, then accompanied to the Board Room.
I was told the Kaizen "committee" would now start one of the weekly meetings on Kaizen improvements, as per "agenda" of the day. My comments would be welcome......
The day's item in the "agenda" was "How to improve and rationalize the distribution of toilet paper and other hygiene products throughout the Company (large-size Company - huge factory....).
Rather astonished, I kept quiet and started my video recording.....
Perhaps you won't believe me, but - for over 1 solid hour (my 1 hour Video Camera tape ran out.....) - the 12 persons in the "committee" debated and debated (in a rather well conducted team work) on "toilet paper" matters (from supply chain issues - to stock management, with great attention to "FIFO" practices - to factory-key-personnel in charge of giving "early warning" signals/notifications on each "area shortages" - etc. etc. etc.)!
I kept very quiet until the end of the meeting, but then grabbed my "stick" (and my 5 lbs hammer....) and started tapping on fingers.....
Over 1 hour of Kaizen meeting to deal with toilet paper internal distribution system (sigh), when they had many and much more important improvement items to deal with!!
They explained: "that was the 'next' item in the Kaizen Agenda.....".
Me: "and what about prioritizing?"
They: "....we prefer to deal with suggested improvements in the same order in which suggestions have been given, in order to give timely feed-backs to those making suggestions....."
Me: "throw away the Suggestion Box Scheme!"
They: "What? That's the way we involve people 'bottom-up', as you recommended......"
Me: "Perhaps I should explain again what 'bottom-up' really means, although I thought my message of last year (and case studies, and videos....) was rather clear..... - so: I shall explain again....." - which I did.....
YES, that could be the negative effect of "traditional Improvement Lists" and "Suggestion Box Schemes"....
Verified regularly over many years, in a dozen different Countries, in many, many industrial/business concerns......
That's where Lean Kaizen comes to the rescue, and that's why Lean Kaizen is so much needed!
The definition of Lean Kaizen is very similar to that of "traditional" Kaizen, but with a small "addendum":
Lean Kaizen means:
continuous, systematic, step-by-step improvement in the Lean direction (in a "bottom-up" style)
The small "addendum" is: in the Lean direction!
Which makes an enormous difference!!
Because, taking into consideration the Lean Direction:
- Improvement now means: increase in Efficiency (core parameter of Productivity) and/or Effectiveness (core parameter of Quality) of a Process! (not of a vague "area"!)
- Maximising the Process' output Value
- While simultaneously minimizing/eliminating the "in-Process" Waste
Lean is the missing link, and the new key-word is PROCESS!
Under the Lean angle of view, Processes need to be improved! Processes fragmented and almost disappeared after decades of enforcing the First Industrial Revolution principles - Smith/Sloan/Taylor style.
Processes full of "processing Waste" - Processes that MUST create output VALUE!
Processes that must become Lean!
With Lean Kaizen the direction for improvement becomes finally crisp and clear - priorities can be set - challenging improvement targets have meaning and foundations - bottom-up involvement can be easily generated among people with lean minds....
In every Organisation - besides the Central Process (the money generation process), there are Core Processes (those that "touch" the Client) and Support Processes (invisible to Clients, but essential to make the entire Organisation function) (more »).
Obviously, under the Lean Kaizen approach, Improvement must primarily be directed to Core Processes - although certain Support Processes may also deserve high improvement priority.....
Now - and only now - a real Improvement Plan can be made! A Lean Master Plan!
Everything required is there:
- ALL (at a certain date) Improvement Projects are listed: each of them has a clear, meaningful title
- With the necessary priorities, with the wanted sequence (i.e. you cannot launch a TPM Autonomous Maintenance project, unless you first provide the necessary training to the concerned operators....)
- With time durations for each project
- With a time-frame/schedule and a deadline for each project - NB: a deadline is vital: without it, an improvement project can last forever and ever.....
- With "milestones"
- Displaying the Improvement Team and the Team Leader for each project - And attached: an estimated budget of costs - potential savings (= Waste eliminated) - and whatever necessary remarks
Wow, what a beauty!
All what is to be done, when, for how long, in what sequence, led by whom, costing how much, etc. etc.
All is there!
This is a true Lean Kaizen-style Plan.
What a difference compared to the "traditional improvement list" - maybe resulting from a "suggestion box" scheme! That meaningless list of items to be improved......
Lean Kaizen is the most essential ingredient of the Lean Management/Lean Thinking philosophies (more »): still today, there isn't a single Organisation in the entire world that can proclaim itself 100% Lean.
Lean is a permanently moving target, there is no end to a Lean Program; every bit and piece of every process can be perfected, Lean is an endless road.....