Self Audits - Internal Audits - Area supervisors to audit their own area

J

Jimmy Olson

#1
Hello everyone. I know that ISO states that audits cannot be performed by people in the same department/work area, but I was wondering if this applies to all audits. The area I am looking at is ESD auditing. Our ESD program is part of our quality system and the current procedure in place calls for the area supervisors to audit their own area. Is this allowable or should it be changed?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Elsmar Forum Sponsor
#2
Jim,
You are correct,"auditors shall not audit their own work". However, in your example if the manager is the assigned auditor he cannot audit his own department. The same applies to the supervisor, if he is the assigned auditor he cannot audit his department for ESD compliance.
 
D

D.Scott

#3
I am with Sam on this one. IMHO, as the manager/supervisor, you are responsible for the activities of the department including any process therein. I think you would have a hard time convincing any auditor that it wasn't the manager/supervisor's own work. To make the case that the manager is disassociated from the work in the department would really be stretching it.

On the other hand a department employee could audit the department as long as his own work wasn't a part of his audit. Just my opinion but I see a big difference there.

Dave
 
#4
What is "work"?

The question here, IMO, revolves around "work". If I am an inspector on 2nd shift, can I audit 1st shift inspection? Can I audit other 1st shift inspectors’ work? If I am a manager, can I audit ANY part of my department?

To answer these, go to the previous line: “Selection of auditors and conduct of audits shall ensure objectivity and impartiality of the audit process.” To me, this is far more important!

In a three-person shop, not auditing your own work may be very difficult. Meeting the “objectivity and impartiality” requirements may or may not be more difficult.
 
R

Roger Eastin

#5
Terminology aside, I think you are all saying the same thing. The "other Dave's" comments are the most important: how do you assure impartiality and objectivity? Whether it is a process or a department, the auditor has to have objectivity. Now I understand this gets a little fuzzy with very small operations, but for most other organizations cross-departmental (to pick a term) auditors should work. Even though I may "own" a part of the purchasing process, for example, I can still audit the other parts and should be able to audit the interfaces impartially. To Richard's original question, I agree with Dave B that one shift ought to be able to audit another shift in most circumstances for these ESD audits. I would not audit my own shift, however.
 
J

Jimmy Olson

#6
Thank you for the information everyone. It seems that this comes down to a question of whose work is being audited. As far as ESD goes, would you be able to audit your area for ESD management since you could argue that it isn't your work? Or is this a real gray area that would be better to just avoid? Thanks.
 

JodiB

Still plugging along
#7
I don't think that a manager should audit his own dept. as a function of the "official" formal internal audit. Obviously he should be performing audit functions on a daily basis. He must know how his dept / process is operating! But for internal audit purposes, a separate and objective view is what is called for. This is the checks and balances system.

From where I sit, if he is the process owner, department manager, whatever you want to call him, ..if he has reporting responsibilities and accountability for the functioning of that process, dept, whatever,..then it is someone else who must be doing the auditing.

It comes down to "who is responsible/accountable for the successful functioning of this process?" and "who will be responsible for taking corrective action should any be needed based on the audit findings?". If the manager is either of these people, he does not belong in the internal audit role.
 
J

Jimmy Olson

#8
Since wording things the right way seems to be an issue I was wondering if this would be acceptable. What if area supervisors did an ESD maintenance inspection each month, and then the overall ESD management of the area was part of our formal internal audit process (and checked by someone else)? Could this same idea also apply to other aspects as well (such as other maintenance programs)? I realize this is probably looking at loopholes, but I am trying to figure out the easiest way for us to do things but still satisfy external auitors.:D
 
M

M Greenaway

#9
When considering the effective auditing of processes it might well be an excellent idea for the process owner to audit the inputs to the process, as he is effectively auditing his suppliers. This could be very useful.

However I would agree that perhaps he is not best placed to give an unbiased opinion on the effectiveness of his own process, the adequacy of the resources, controls, etc.
 

JodiB

Still plugging along
#10
Jim Wade said:


Is that what ISO 9001 calls for, Lucinda, or is it just your (no doubt excellent) opinion?

rgds Jim
Ye gads man! Don't make me start quoting ISO 9001 instead of reading it for yourself!:) I know you have a copy of it somewhere all marked up with highlighters and doodles.:vfunny:

9001 does call for the selection of auditors and the conduct of audits to ensure objectivity and impartiality of the audit process. This can hardly be the case if a mgr. (with bonus riding on his process's reported margins) grades his own paper. I'd say he was pretty partial, wouldn't you?

And 9000 defines the audit itself as being an "independent" process. In other words: not a function of day-to-day information gathering which is an identified part of a functioning process, such as a manager might do. It is a process wholly unto itself for a specific purpose.

I sorely lack a copy of ISO 19011 so I can't further explore the definitional technicalities of internal audit, but I do think that I have a fairly clear grasp of the concept and the intent.

A manager is not impartial to his own process or department. IMEO :)
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
R Handling Quality Self-Audits on Outsourced Products Misc. Quality Assurance and Business Systems Related Topics 5
T Formal Q Self Assessment - Problem with assigning Product and Process Customer and Company Specific Requirements 1
G Self Assessment Audit from a new potential customer General Auditing Discussions 3
M CE self-certification for Class I device (face mask) EU Medical Device Regulations 9
M Informational US FDA – Ear, Nose, and Throat Devices; Classification of the Self-Fitting Air-Conduction Hearing Aid Medical Device and FDA Regulations and Standards News 0
K Intended Use-Class I Self Certified - Intended Use and Indications for Use statements EU Medical Device Regulations 1
Ed Panek Part 11 Self Certify Memo - What else should it cover? Qualification and Validation (including 21 CFR Part 11) 5
M Informational TGA Consultation: Review of the regulation of certain self-testing IVDs in Australia Medical Device and FDA Regulations and Standards News 0
J Good Documentation Practices Self Test? ISO 13485:2016 - Medical Device Quality Management Systems 6
C CE marking for general IVD (self-certified) & ISO 13485 QMS requirements - auditing EU Medical Device Regulations 6
MichaelDRoach Oganization's Self Declaration of Conformance to ISO 28000 wording example wanted Supply Chain Security Management Systems 1
M Medical Device News TGA – Regulator Performance Framework: Self-assessment Report, July 2017 to June 2018 Medical Device and FDA Regulations and Standards News 0
A Selling CE marked self-test in Malta - any additional requirements? EU Medical Device Regulations 0
M CE self-certify, or needs testing by 3rd party? CE Marking (Conformité Européene) / CB Scheme 12
M Notified Body Involvement with Self Declared Products EU Medical Device Regulations 7
S Help: Need Control Self Assessment Questionnaire for HR Departmental Functions Process Audits and Layered Process Audits 0
T IVD - Self Declaration - Technical File - Template wanted Various Other Specifications, Standards, and related Requirements 9
R Documenting Self-Training and Effectiveness - ISO 13485:2016 Training - Internal, External, Online and Distance Learning 4
K ISO 13485:2016 Self Certification for Class I (annex 9) Stand-Alone Software? ISO 13485:2016 - Medical Device Quality Management Systems 3
S ISO9001:2015 and ISO14001:2015 Readiness/Self Evaluation Checklists wanted ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 2
N MDD Class I Medical Device Self Declaration Articles/Supplementary Documents EU Medical Device Regulations 1
A Self-study plan to improve fluency in English speaking, writing After Work and Weekend Discussion Topics 3
Crusader Interval for Self-Calibrating Measurement Device? Calibration Frequency (Interval) 15
T Transition Time for Self Declared IVDs EU Medical Device Regulations 3
Z IVD Self Test Pregnancy - Assessment Route? EU Medical Device Regulations 5
S Anyone know the self-selection study for home use medical device Other US Medical Device Regulations 2
D Off-Label Self Promotion - What to do EU Medical Device Regulations 3
B Own Brand Labelling and Distributors - Self Test IVD's EU Medical Device Regulations 3
S Creating goals and objectives with targets and measurables for self-evaluations Management Review Meetings and related Processes 2
C Help with Risk/Benefit Analysis Self-help Device for Diabetics ISO 14971 - Medical Device Risk Management 3
B Self Contained Biological Indicators as internal PCD Other Medical Device Related Standards 2
T Self Declaration for CE Class I, Non-Invasive Medical Device EU Medical Device Regulations 10
R Self-Certification Is Not a Real Thing - an IAF article Registrars and Notified Bodies 13
T Should a supplier self assessment form be a controlled document? Document Control Systems, Procedures, Forms and Templates 9
C Vendor Self-Survey to Qualify Vendors/Suppliers - AVL Question ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 2
S Annex III self declared IVD to be in use with Annex II List B IVD EU Medical Device Regulations 1
S SAE AS9015 Supplier Self Verification Process - Delegation Programs. AS9100, IAQG, NADCAP and Aerospace related Standards and Requirements 1
B FDA Product Classification - Self Treatment Software Applications 21 CFR Part 820 - US FDA Quality System Regulations (QSR) 4
P Changing from contract manufactured to self manufactured 21 CFR Part 820 - US FDA Quality System Regulations (QSR) 2
A R2 Certification vs Self Declaration to ISO 14001 and OHSAS 18001 ISO 14001:2015 Specific Discussions 3
Marc Ford - Self-parking technology called Fully Assisted Parking Aid World News 1
L IVDD 98/79/EEC - Can I self declare? EU Medical Device Regulations 2
P ISO/TS 16949:2009 Compliance - Self Declaration Audit IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 4
B CCNA (Cisco Certified Network Associate) Self Study Help? Professional Certifications and Degrees 3
T ASQ CQA (Certified Quality Auditor) - Self - study help Professional Certifications and Degrees 3
Ronen E MHRA Publishes Guidance for Notified Bodies on Regulation of IVDs for Self Testing EU Medical Device Regulations 0
D Self-certification of LVD Electronic Device & Charger CE Marking (Conformité Européene) / CB Scheme 4
V ISO10002:2004 (Guidelines for Handling Customer Complaints) Self Assessment Checklist Customer Complaints 5
rob73 Length of validity of a self certified Declaration of Conformity (DoC) for CE mark EU Medical Device Regulations 4
N Is RoHS issued only by self declaration process? RoHS, REACH, ELV, IMDS and Restricted Substances 3

Similar threads

Top Bottom