Sorting Instruction Template wanted

Lewis

Inactive Registered Visitor
#1
Good Day All!!!

As with most manufacturing organizations, the need to sort/rework product becomes an absolute necessity at times. Especially when dealing with the automotive industry. The personnel that actually performs the sorting function are not necessarily the most savvy "free-thinkers" of the world, if you know what I mean. Thus, the need to provide written sorting instructions that provide clear direction becomes obviously apparent.

Does anyone know where I can find a simple template for sorting instructions that I can use and/or modify? Any feedback would be greatly appreciated!
 

reynald

Quite Involved in Discussions
#2
Re: Looking for Sorting Instruction Template

We have a lot of sorting process, we even have a sorting machine.:rolleyes:
Can you provide details of the process (i.e, sorting after inspection, sorting after testing, etc) so we can help you more?
 

Wes Bucey

Consultant/Advisor
Forum Moderator
#3
Re: Looking for Sorting Instruction Template

Good Day All!!!

As with most manufacturing organizations, the need to sort/rework product becomes an absolute necessity at times. Especially when dealing with the automotive industry. The personnel that actually performs the sorting function are not necessarily the most savvy "free-thinkers" of the world, if you know what I mean. Thus, the need to provide written sorting instructions that provide clear direction becomes obviously apparent.

Does anyone know where I can find a simple template for sorting instructions that I can use and/or modify? Any feedback would be greatly appreciated!
The modern concept is to avoid text instructions in favor of pictures and good/bad samples exhibiting each characteristic under scrutiny. The point is to ASSUME an inspector has NEVER seen the product before and to concentrate focus on ONLY the suspect characteristic during the sort to avoid delays and wasted time examining characteristics (attributes?) NOT under scrutiny.

It may be important to remember a "sort" is not an inspection like a first article inspection, but simply a pass/fail decision on suspect dimensions or attributes.

Typically, a sort is required when only a portion of the entire production is suspect and the nonconforming characteristic has already been identified. If there is a probability of DIFFERENT (or multiple) characteristics being nonconforming, it is probably better to use higher level personnel who can more easily identify whether a part is conforming or nonconforming.

The supplier should already have a pretty good idea of root cause BEFORE the sort to assure other characteristics were kept under control.
 
Last edited:

reynald

Quite Involved in Discussions
#4
Re: Looking for Sorting Instruction Template

The modern concept is to avoid text instructions in favor of pictures and good/bad samples exhibiting each characteristic under scrutiny. The point is to ASSUME an inspector has NEVER seen the product before and to concentrate focus on ONLY the suspect characteristic during the sort to avoid delays and wasted time examining characteristics (attributes?) NOT under scrutiny.


Yes, i agree with Wes.
In one of out test processes, the computer monitor flashes colors to the operator,each color having a classification code. The operator does not even have to memorize what the code means, but just need to put the product on a bin/tray that has the same color as what the monitor flashes.

This is easy for a process that do measurement, but for processes involving inspection and judgment it not as easy. But the same concept is applicable--use pictures/graphics and align them to the sorting bins.
 

Caster

An Early Cover
#5
As always Wes has nailed it.

The best example I ever saw, was a dedicated sort area set up in front of the plant managers office window. Needless to say, the location drove improvement!

A sort instruction was created for each sort before it began, and this was before digital cameras or software so they would cut out Polaroids (remember them?), make hand sketches, or place marked up samples on table. Anything to get the intent across. Simple is best. And of course the sorters was given hands on training before they started and were closely supervised throughout the entire sort. Of course.

I only saw this once, at a really good supplier. Most other plants hire temp people to sort and tuck them away in the darkest corner.

Toyota wants all job instructions to fit on one 11x17 sheet with photos and as little text as possible. And this piece of paper must be within arms reach of every person. In my experience it is way harder to do this than to write a 10 page document in 7 point type that no one will ever read! To be brief you must totally understand what you want to explain!

If you have ever been placed on third party containment in automotive you understand the special joy of paying top dollar to a third party to have your parts sorted by people who were pulled off the street that day...after their sort you are out of pocket lots of money and the parts on cars are likely not much better...
 

Lewis

Inactive Registered Visitor
#6
Re: Looking for Sorting Instruction Template

Thanks to all for the information. I whole-heartedly agree that visual aids are the best way to go, which also happens to be what I had in mind. Depending upon the product and what it's being sorted for, every sort can be different. My search for a template was an effort to standardize the method as much as possible so that I can train others on how to write a sort instruction.
Again, thanks for the information and I will post my final sort template when complete.
 
Top