Stimulate some reader response by questioning the Value of Six Sigma

CarolX

Super Moderator
Super Moderator
#1
the value of 6 sigma

Hello all,

I normally do not post in this subject because this is not my area of expertise. But I came across an intersting article in this months issue of Quality Digest and thought I might spur some discussion on the subject.

The article was written by James Harrington.
In the June issue of Quality Digest, I tried to stimulate some reader response by questioning the value of Six Sigma.

I offered a free performance improvement book and CD-ROM set, to the first five people who provided me with a publishable case study of a service process that was performing at the Six Sigma level. I thought I'd be deluged with hundreds of excellent examples that would be well worth my investment. Well, I still have four of the book and CD-ROM sets. But--surprise, surprise--I was deluged with e-mails agreeing with my negative position and only one "hate mail" from a Black Belt consultant, who was angry because I dared to question the Six Sigma approach.
Give it a read and let me know what you gurus think about the subject.

Regards,
CarolX
 
Elsmar Forum Sponsor
M

Michael T

#2
Whhhhooooo boy!!!!

Hi Carol...

Let's see - - first of all, the "crack" being heard is the can of worms being opened... :biglaugh: Great thread!!

While I would hardly call myself a guru, I will chime in with my 2 cents... ;) I like Jim Harrington's work. He is usually straight up and right on target with his observations and doesn't pull any punches when it comes to poor quality. When I read his article - the only thing I could think was, "Amen Brother!" There have been several people who have questioned the validity and value of 6S (both in Quality Digest and on this list). While 6S has its strong points, I think that using a financial bar to determine whether a potential project merits attention is absolutely stupid. There are way too many good projects that I can think of that wouldn't directly net or save a single dime, but should be done none-the-less, because they are good for the stakeholders and hence, good for business.

Jim's example of ASQ and the video tapes is all too telling about the value of 6S to the customer. :eek: One would think that ASQ, of all entities, would have more on the ball with respect to the quality of products & services offered. Guess not. :(

By far, the most telling bit of information from Jim's article was the fact that only ONE person was able to provide him with a "publishable case study of a service process that was performing at the Six Sigma level." One? That is an incredible indictment of 6S and its value to business.

Cheers!!!
 

Kevin Mader

One of THE Original Covers!
Staff member
Admin
#3
Mike,

Nice post! Carol, good topic!

Harrington’s article was well written. Nice capturing of the evolution process, brief but descript. However, I could give the same condemnation in regards his software. One should not throw stones if…..

I agree with you that this was an indictment of Six Sigma, more so the ideology than the tools themselves. The financial overtone is more than I can bear, I’m afraid.

Regards,

Kevin
 

Randy

Super Moderator
#4
OK...I'll jump in on this one.

I'm not even close to a 6 sigma anything. All I know is what I read here and from periodicals. All those charts, and graphs and stuff effect me to the point of making my bowels rumble.:eek:

The point I want to address is the money thing that my buddy Kevin (hi Kevin :) ) can't bear.

Kevin are smokin' something you ain't sharing?:ko:

How long would you or me or anybody else stay employeed and well fed if business wasn't interested in cutting cost and improving profit like a bunch of Ferengi's (for all you Trekkers)?
Quite honestly six sigma should include other tools like the "Rules of Acquisition".:cool:

I think Mr. Harrington is right in his assessment of six sigma. And I believe that if there was no "PROFIT" in it six sigma would go the way of the 4 track tape.

Let's get more Black Belts, more Green Belts, Brown Belts, White Belts and whatever other guru name you can dream of. As long as they save money and make more profit in the name of quality (whatever that truly is) more power to them.

See ya

:bigwave:
 

Marc

Hunkered Down for the Duration
Staff member
Admin
#5
The power of the preacher will over power most of the people in the end and they will believe anything. This is to say, if you say it loud enough and long enough people will eventually believe it. Folklore is the extreme.

Six sigma as a tool - OK. But all the hype and advertising give it legitimacy it doesn't deserve.
 
E

energy

#6
Do You?

Originally posted by Randy

Let's get more Black Belts, more Green Belts, Brown Belts, White Belts and whatever other guru name you can dream of.
Does any body out there have a real "Belt" in the martial arts? The entire concept of using the term "Black belt" is just a marketing tool. "I have a black belt in 6 Sigma" makes as much sense as saying "I'm an Astronaut" because I got a NASA ring in a box of crackers. Anytime I see a phrase coined because of a popular theme, (the craze in Martial Arts movies), it annoys me because it designed to catch the eye with no real substance. Quality Systems are basically the same. The "fads" are catchy because those that promulgate the "system" appear to be a step ahead of the game. In fact, they don't have a clue. It's new. It has to be better. Not. We recently went through "Lean" Mfg. training and they tossed out the "Six Sigma" term repeatedly. Playing the devil's advocate, I asked "What are the advantages of Six Sigma vs the other Quality Programs.?" The obvious confusion amongst the trainers and their audience was very apparent. They were using the "Buzz Word" to try to impress the class without a shred of proof, or any information for that matter. Yes, I have a real Black belt that required years of training and discipline to obtain. When I see this term used to describe some Company's or Quality Geek's accomplishments, it makes me boil.:mad: So, let's take that Black belt in Six Sigma tools and pack it where it really belongs. Because this thread is rated "G", I'll leave it there!:biglaugh: :smokin:
 

Randy

Super Moderator
#7
Hey Energy.....

On Okinawa where I studied martial arts as a kid in the early 60's a belt meant you didn't need a rope to hold up your pants (this is for real just like Mr. Myagi said).

There may be some parallel meaning with all this colored belt stuff.

Just a thought.
 

Marc

Hunkered Down for the Duration
Staff member
Admin
#8
This link self destructed because of the way Quality Digest's site is set up so weird.
 
A

Al Dyer

#9
The only belt I ever received was a black one from my mother when I "acted" up.

We all know people who have degrees and initials attached to their business cards, we also know whether those people really know what they are talking about.
 
D

D.Scott

#10
Thanks Marc for the wonderful link to the unbiased appraisal of the world of six sigma.

"Mr Jones, who should I give this six sigma survey to?"
"Give it to Nutcracker, he handles all the six sigma stuff."

"Mr Nutcracker, do you feel six sigma has added value to your company?"
"Certainly it does, why else would my company spend thousands a year on it?"

"What do you feel is the single most important thing your company has gained from six sigma?"
"Are you kidding? They got me!!"

Wouldn't it be nice if just once a survey were done without involving those affected by the outcome of the survey? Sorry to be so negative but these things really irk me.

Dave
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
P AIM 7351731 RFID reader immunity Other US Medical Device Regulations 2
K Addition of a test reader to existing CE marked product. Other ISO and International Standards and European Regulations 2
B Alternatives to Google Reader - is Feedly a good option? After Work and Weekend Discussion Topics 2
Jim Wynne Do you have an e-reader? Tell us about it Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 16
Manix Using Acrobat Ver 5 when you have Reader Ver 8 Installed! After Work and Weekend Discussion Topics 13
M CE requirements for invitro diagnostic device which has an electronic reader ISO 13485:2016 - Medical Device Quality Management Systems 6
J Customer Complaint Response 21 CFR Part 820 - US FDA Quality System Regulations (QSR) 3
Govind Informational ISO COVID-19 response: freely available ISO standards Other ISO and International Standards and European Regulations 1
A ISO 13485 - Clause 8.3.3 appropriate actions in response to nonconforming product ISO 13485:2016 - Medical Device Quality Management Systems 2
P Corrective Action Response for Missed bumps on brake press Manufacturing and Related Processes 2
I "On the job training" as a response to how someone was trained? ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 75
R How long to wait for Notified Body Response - Potentially significant change to a medical device CE Marking (Conformité Européene) / CB Scheme 6
I "We don't have enough resources" as an Audit Non-conformance Response General Auditing Discussions 14
M Medical Device News MHRA releases response to consultation on EU exit no-deal legislative proposals Medical Device and FDA Regulations and Standards News 0
S Requirements for Interval Measurement test & Frequency Response test clarification IEC 60601 - Medical Electrical Equipment Safety Standards Series 0
O QRQC (quick response quality control) methodology in automotive industry IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 3
S Formal written response to a corrective action? Nonconformance and Corrective Action 9
S Response Surface Method to create design matrix in Minitab Using Minitab Software 5
A Taguchi Minitab - Continuous Data - What should I choose as response variable? Using Minitab Software 3
C Medical Device Malfunction - Customer Complaint - Response vs. Correction Other US Medical Device Regulations 3
W Nonconformance Recurrence Response Help General Auditing Discussions 4
N Survey to Customers Regarding Our Complaint Response Time Customer Complaints 7
N Customer Complaint - Rapid Response Containment Procedure Customer Complaints 2
D Tracking response time with individual label I.D. Statistical Analysis Tools, Techniques and SPC 6
K Fast Response Tracking Board (QSB+) Customer and Company Specific Requirements 6
S What are the next steps after providing response to FDA 483 ? US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) 7
Wes Bucey Baffled by no response to your job application? Career and Occupation Discussions 6
M Please help to analyze Response Surface Methodology by using Minitab 16 Using Minitab Software 6
H FDA Response Time for Amendments? 21 CFR Part 820 - US FDA Quality System Regulations (QSR) 1
S Delegation of Response to Next Level ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 2
Mikishots How to handle CAR (Corrective Action Request) Scope vs. Timely Response Nonconformance and Corrective Action 9
F Response to ISO 13485 Audit Minor Nonconformances ISO 13485:2016 - Medical Device Quality Management Systems 6
T Variation in values of the levels in Factorial/Response surface design Using Minitab Software 1
C Optimize One Response with Three Variables Using Minitab Software 8
M Customer Satisfaction Survey - Poor Response ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 11
T Response to ISO 17025 Proficiency Test z score ISO 17025 related Discussions 7
R Supplier CAR response scoring Nonconformance and Corrective Action 10
G Setting up a 3 Factor, 2 Level,2 response DOE in Minitab Using Minitab Software 7
A Effects of categorical variables on single response Using Minitab Software 9
somashekar About NC (Nonconformance) Type and days for CA (Corrective Action) Response... ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 8
D Showing the Response Surface Experimental Point in MiniTab Using Minitab Software 5
M AS 4706 (Personal Response Systems) & AS 3811 (Patient Alarm Systems) Equivalents? Other ISO and International Standards and European Regulations 4
N Closed Customer Complaint Response Form Examples? Customer Complaints 3
A 483 Response Letter - Are there any Special Formal or Content related Requirements? 21 CFR Part 820 - US FDA Quality System Regulations (QSR) 16
R Risk Register, Risk Analysis and Risk Response/Treatment IEC 27001 - Information Security Management Systems (ISMS) 5
W Best quadratic subset for analyzing a Response Surface Design with Minitab 15 Using Minitab Software 6
S Need Help with Response Surface Optimization Using Minitab Software 4
A FDA 483 Warning Letter Response Time Requirements 21 CFR Part 820 - US FDA Quality System Regulations (QSR) 1
J QRQC (Quick Response Quality Control) Training Material or Information Quality Tools, Improvement and Analysis 3
R Rules for DOE / Hypothesis Testing and ATTRIBUTE RESPONSE? Six Sigma 2

Similar threads

Top Bottom