The 'Thanks' button and the 'Karma' (aka Reputation) Systems

If possible, should "thanks" contribute to Karma?

  • Yes

    Votes: 14 56.0%
  • No

    Votes: 2 8.0%
  • No preference

    Votes: 9 36.0%

  • Total voters
    25
  • Poll closed .

Atul Khandekar

Quite Involved in Discussions
#31
Just curious..

What is the difference between 'karma' and 'karma power'?
In simple terms, Karma Power is the number of points you award others when you give them Karma. These points get added to that person's Karma (reputation score). So your Karma is the points you have accumulated. You can check this through your UserCP. As you post more and recieve more Karma, your Karma power also goes up (there is a formula that calculates your karma power).
 
Elsmar Forum Sponsor

hogheavenfarm

Quite Involved in Discussions
#32
I know this has been a long ongoing thing, but I see it this way. "Thanks" is part of life in a quality career. It is something we should be doing every day, as a constant reminder that our team is not made up of one, but many, who are all working together to achieve a goal.
"Karma" - does not relate well to me, or in the same way as a "Thank you". I don't see the "quality" connection, it is more of a "persona" thing.
 

Coury Ferguson

Moderator here to help
Staff member
Super Moderator
#33
I know this has been a long ongoing thing, but I see it this way. "Thanks" is part of life in a quality career. It is something we should be doing every day, as a constant reminder that our team is not made up of one, but many, who are all working together to achieve a goal.
"Karma" - does not relate well to me, or in the same way as a "Thank you". I don't see the "quality" connection, it is more of a "persona" thing.
Valid points.
 
D

D.Scott

#34
My main objection to connecting the Thanks button to Karma is simply -

People use the Thanks button to say "Thanks", not "I think your answer is good (or useful)".

Look at a typical thread started by a newbie asking a question. In many threads (almost all threads started by by posters outside the US) you will find a "Thanks" on virtually every post in the thread. You will see a post with no response other than "Welcome to the Cove" to which the OP has politely said "Thanks".

If we use the Thanks Button to determine, in any way, the professional credibility or knowledge of the people here we are kidding ourselves. I also think the number of times a person has been thanked and the number of times a person has thanked someone is completely irrelevant.

A word about Karma while I am on the soap box. There is a complex formula behind the Karma calculation and I am sure it has been well thought out and serves some purpose unknown to us mortals. I have turned off my Karma because I passionately disagree with the concept of "Karma Power". For those who haven't been listening, "Karma Power" is the value added when an individual gives you Karma. My problem with the system is simply a "sour grapes" argument that my opinion of your post and the value applied for me saying so should be the same as the next guy's.

Why should John Doe's (there is no John Doe here to my knowledge) Karma carry more weight than mine or anyone else's? We are setting up the false impression that the higher the Karma Power and the more Karma you have, the more knowledgeable and credible you are.

As for my opinion, I think "Thanks" and "Karma" are a distraction from the concept of The Cove. They become narcissistic flags to wave so everybody can see how wonderful you are. The idea of The Cove is to meet here as equals in the quality profession, share ideas, help each other, and make friends we can relate to. Every poster should be treated equally whether they be new or a founding member. I see no room for ego inflating in this forum. Next thing you know we will be nominating posts for "Oscars" for a "Post of the Month" award.

BTW, I voted NO on the poll.

Dave
 

Jim Wynne

Staff member
Admin
#35
My main objection to connecting the Thanks button to Karma is simply -

People use the Thanks button to say "Thanks", not "I think your answer is good (or useful)".

Look at a typical thread started by a newbie asking a question. In many threads (almost all threads started by by posters outside the US) you will find a "Thanks" on virtually every post in the thread. You will see a post with no response other than "Welcome to the Cove" to which the OP has politely said "Thanks".

If we use the Thanks Button to determine, in any way, the professional credibility or knowledge of the people here we are kidding ourselves. I also think the number of times a person has been thanked and the number of times a person has thanked someone is completely irrelevant.

A word about Karma while I am on the soap box. There is a complex formula behind the Karma calculation and I am sure it has been well thought out and serves some purpose unknown to us mortals. I have turned off my Karma because I passionately disagree with the concept of "Karma Power". For those who haven't been listening, "Karma Power" is the value added when an individual gives you Karma. My problem with the system is simply a "sour grapes" argument that my opinion of your post and the value applied for me saying so should be the same as the next guy's.

Why should John Doe's (there is no John Doe here to my knowledge) Karma carry more weight than mine or anyone else's? We are setting up the false impression that the higher the Karma Power and the more Karma you have, the more knowledgeable and credible you are.

As for my opinion, I think "Thanks" and "Karma" are a distraction from the concept of The Cove. They become narcissistic flags to wave so everybody can see how wonderful you are. The idea of The Cove is to meet here as equals in the quality profession, share ideas, help each other, and make friends we can relate to. Every poster should be treated equally whether they be new or a founding member. I see no room for ego inflating in this forum. Next thing you know we will be nominating posts for "Oscars" for a "Post of the Month" award.

BTW, I voted NO on the poll.

Dave
Well said. I nominate this for Post of the Month honors. :biglaugh:
 

hogheavenfarm

Quite Involved in Discussions
#36
I agree with the fact that people simply thank others for replying, and as was pointed out, it is prevalent among newbies, but I still cannot connect "Karma" with competence. I will thank someone who I think has posted a valuable answer or post, just like 'real life'. I have difficulty associating "Karma" with "competence", or even "usefulness". Maybe it is just my Western upbringing. It sounds like a rating system is more what you are after, or a poll showing "best post answer". (See LinkedIn "Best Answer" system for how this works.) I freely admit it boils down to my interpretation of what "Karma" is to me, and I think this reflects the feelings of many members as well.
 

Marc

Hunkered Down for the Duration
Staff member
Admin
#39
I do not connect the validity or value of any post by Karma or Thanks. I see them only as someone expressing appreciation for an attempt at helping. Nothing more, nothing less. I do not now, nor have I ever, associated either 'Thanks' or Karma with the professional credibility or knowledge of a poster. I really don't think many people do.

There is no way in this forum to assess the credibility of any poster other than to make a personal judgment by looking at that users posts in general and in contrast to answers others give. Even then, it's a 'best guess'. If anyone is using Karma or Thanks to assess the validity of someones posts, my opinion is they are using a false guide.

I put in the 'Thanks' mod because I believe people like to know that others do appreciate their help. I could disable both 'Thanks' and Karma. From a world view, we could also eliminate any recognition of someone trying to help someone else if we look at it from a 'sour grapes' view. If someone helps me out, why send a card, or buy them a dinner, or even say thanks? And if someone does tell me thanks, what does that have to do with my professional credibility or knowledge?

As to the Karma formula, is it so bad to give a person credit for the length of time they have been visiting and related factors? Are the clubs like the Lions Club wrong to give out recognition certificates or other acknowledgment to those who have been in the club for years helping people out? Should clubs like that give equal weight to someone who joined last year vs. someone who has been involved for 20 years or more? Can we put in a 'sour grapes' argument in regard to such recognition? Sure we can. Just because someone has been around for 20 years helping out they're no better than the guy who just joined, is he? I think the 'Better Than' argument is irrelevant. I don't think that 'better than' is part of it.

Taken to the extreme, we could easily extrapolate that to the world. No one should thank anyone for anything, because if they do it is nothing more than a 'flag they can wave' in others faces, and it is a contest. There should be no recognition of appreciation for anything.

My view of both Karma and Thanks is simply that they are indicators of people expressing appreciation, unrelated to professional credibility or knowledge. They are no more than 'Thank You' notes people send when they appreciate something someone did for them. In my opinion, reading anything more into Karma and Thanks is silly. If we cannot share ideas, help each other, and make friends AND tell others Thank You! now and again, I cannot even conceive of what it would be like - Here or anywhere. It's not a contest. If you do a kindness for someone and they say Thank You, does that make it a contest and therefore bad in some way?

As a last comment, I have not seen anyone 'waving a flag' or in any way 'advertising' their Karma or number of Thanks. I do think some (many) people are proud of their Karma and/or Thanks. Some people (my self included) do like recognition from time to time for things they do. In my eyes, that doesn't mean we're in a contest. When I see someone with a high Thanks count, for example, I do see it as an indicator that many people appreciate a person. I do not think that is bad. We do share ideas, help each other, and make friends here. I don't believe that Thanks or Karma in any way impedes what we do here. I personally believe that Karma and Thanks are also incentives for people to come back and to help and interact more. People do tend to help more when they feel their efforts are appreciated, and I do not think that is a bad thing.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
M Thanks for the help Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 0
Marc Interesting Discussion We have food safety laws thanks to 19th century “poison squad” Food Safety - ISO 22000, HACCP (21 CFR 120) 1
bobdoering Thanks to those that tried to fill the void Covegratulations 2
T Special Thanks to Everyone in this Forum! AS9100, IAQG 9100, Nadcap and related Aerospace Standards and Requirements 6
S Thanks from a newbie Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 4
A Thanks for your help in the Elsmar forum IEC 60601 - Medical Electrical Equipment Safety Standards Series 2
Wes Bucey Sucker Punch ("thanks for the free consulting, but no job for you!") Career and Occupation Discussions 8
H ISO 9001 - Thanks for the help ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 6
harrysons Thanks to Elsmar Cove - Successful TS16949:2009 Certification Covegratulations 10
T Nissan acronym: THANKS? Customer and Company Specific Requirements 3
G What is the proper Thanks Giving turkey sampling size? Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 9
G VERY easy savory baked Thanks Giving party treat Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 0
S ISO 9001: 2008 Certification Success - Thanks Covegratulations 9
J Back from Europe, no thanks to BA Travel - Hotels, Motels, Planes and Trains 12
A Recommended for AS9100B Certification! Thanks! AS9100, IAQG 9100, Nadcap and related Aerospace Standards and Requirements 4
Sidney Vianna Thanks Given to Others in Forum Posts Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 9
M closed thanks Document Control Systems, Procedures, Forms and Templates 1
K Successful Audit: Thanks for your help! ISO 13485:2016 - Medical Device Quality Management Systems 10
M Changing the CNC program - Money Saving Idea - Thanks to all of you. Manufacturing and Related Processes 1
J Thanks Everyone Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 4
D Urgently need VDA6.3 guideline ! Thanks. VDA Standards - Germany's Automotive Standards 12
SteelMaiden Give Thanks - Thanksgiving Day in the US - November 2006 Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 14
Wes Bucey Thanks for giving me the opportunity to give a little bit back Philosophy, Gurus, Innovation and Evolution 20
J Thanks To All Our Veterans Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 15
C Thanks for the help guys ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 4
J How to use the six sigma in supply chain? thanks Six Sigma 3
J What is difference between the goal of PPAP with APQP, thanks APQP and PPAP 4
Q Registration Audit done! Thanks for all your help! Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 4
N Big Thanks Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 3
M Thanks for the help with the usefull tips and guidance Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 2
S We Made it to TS 16949 Certification - THANKS! IATF 16949 - Automotive Quality Systems Standard 27
Marc My Continuing Thanks to the Moderators, financial Contributors and the 'Regulars'! Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 5
B Giant thanks to Marc and all the Covers! ISO Upgrade with Zero NCs! ISO 9000, ISO 9001, and ISO 9004 Quality Management Systems Standards 10
A Thanks,Marc Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 3
B IEC 60601-2-43 - Clause 203.6.103 - Physical button? IEC 60601 - Medical Electrical Equipment Safety Standards Series 1
A Torque Value for Different types of Fasteners (Socket Head, Button Head, CSK) Manufacturing and Related Processes 2
H Secondary button cells (LIR2540) in medical products Other Medical Device Related Standards 1
A Standards for Emergency Button for a Dental Laser IEC 60601 - Medical Electrical Equipment Safety Standards Series 2
J Excel Macros - "Button" on a form that executes a macro Excel .xls Spreadsheet Templates and Tools 8
Jim Wynne How to save money on type 394 button-cell batteries Coffee Break and Water Cooler Discussions 5
J PPAP - Same product, different color new PPAP? Small plastic button APQP and PPAP 3
J Button Test - Tactility Criteria Statistical Analysis Tools, Techniques and SPC 12
BradM Covegratulations to BevD - 15,000 Karma points and a silver star Covegratulations 15
Sidney Vianna Covegratulations to Ajit Basrur - 15,000 Karma points and a silver star Covegratulations 22
Similar threads












































Top Bottom