The Elsmar Cove Business Standards Discussion Forums More Free Files Forum Discussion Thread Post Attachments Listing Elsmar Cove Discussion Forums Main Page
Welcome to what was The Original Cayman Cove Forums!
This thread is carried over and continued in the Current Elsmar Cove Forums

Search the Elsmar Cove!

Wooden Line
This is a "Frozen" Legacy Forum.
Most links on this page do NOT work.
Discussions since 2001 are HERE

Owl Line

The New Elsmar Cove Forums   The New Elsmar Cove ForumsThe Elsmar Cove Forums
  Occupations in Quality Assurance
  ASQ - Any Real Value?

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | preferences | faq

UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone! next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   ASQ - Any Real Value?
Marc Smith
Cheech Wizard

Posts: 4367
From:West Chester, OH, USA

posted 19 August 2001 11:42 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Marc Smith   Click Here to Email Marc Smith     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
This is from a NG that I found interesting. I happen to agree.
Newsgroups: misc.industry.quality
Subject: Re: ASQ Certification Exam
Date: Thu, 16 Aug 2001 16:00:19 GMT
Organization: RoadRunner - TampaBay

Jon wrote .
> The value of the certificate? It should help you find a better paying
> According to ASQ data, Certified workers earn more on average, than those
> without.

Not to be TOO cynical, but of *course* ASQ is going to tell you it's certifications are valuable. I'd like to see independent data some day.

The professional certification program has been a great way for ASQ to shift its focus from SERVING the quality community to SELLING to it. The society does little more now than sell its products and services, and publish articles that ... well, sell its products and services. Compare its output with that of Quality Digest (a free journal that's not afraid to critique Six Sigma), and you can see what I mean.

The merits of ASQ certification are murky, but it's basically "what you do with it." Some of the companies I work with think certification is a good thing, but most see it as an expensive open-book test and a way for people to litter their letterhead with lots of abbreviations.

Specifically speaking to CQA, of which I have the most familiarity, more companies (including mine) are refusing to acknowledge it at all. I want more than a Mastercard receipt for a test as evidence of someone's ability to effectively audit systems. For auditing certification, the current best means is IRCA or RAB, where the test is real auditing, not writing essays about auditing.

>maybe it helps them get the choice jobs, or maybe the ones in
> better jobs are just more motivated to certify. No matter, many employers
> will only hire those with cert's.

And many won't. In fact, I tell people to challenge companies that require it, and explain the weaknesses in the ASQ certification system to the employer. The important thing there is not to come off as a person who is making excuses for not being certified, but someone who has a legitimate position on the subject.

> ASQ has loads of info on the exams. All you need to do is ask.

And provide a valid credit card number and exiration date.

The thing is, ASQ's role has tremendous potential; it's a shame to see the quality community so ill-served by the quasi-commercial marketing machine it's become. The good thing is that there are alternatives.


Comments folks?

IP: Logged

Forum Contributor

Posts: 33
From:Southfield, MI
Registered: May 2001

posted 20 August 2001 07:28 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for tomvehoski   Click Here to Email tomvehoski     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I have switched jobs five times since 1996 (all my idea and all improvements to the previous). During interviews I found that interviewers were impressed that I had a CQT, CQA, CQE, and CQMgr. Most paid more attention to these than to my A.S. and B.S. degrees. I'm sure it helped with a couple jobs. Also as a consultant it helps me "prove" to clients that I know a little bit about quality.


IP: Logged

Al Dyer
Forum Wizard

Posts: 814
From:Lapeer, MI USA
Registered: Oct 2000

posted 20 August 2001 08:49 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Al Dyer   Click Here to Email Al Dyer     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I agree that the ASQ has probably evolved past it's original purpose and turned more to sales as its focus. The bigger benefit is with the local ASQ chapters. I was the treasurer for one in Michigan and their goal was to educate and train people at as low a cost as possible.

I have a CQT and have it noted on my resume and such. Never once have I been asked about it. Does it hurt to have the CQT? No, and I'm sure it has helped to some extent. I have found that employers and customers focus more on my other training in specialized quality fields such as auditing, APQP, FMEA, PPAP, QOS, networks etc... and past accomplishments.


IP: Logged

Forum Contributor

Posts: 36
From:Cincinnati, Ohio
Registered: Apr 2001

posted 20 August 2001 12:29 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for JRKH     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
When I first entered the quality arena as an inspector, I started reading. I learned there was so much more out there than inspection. Juran, Deming, TQM, SPC etc.....
Then, as I progress in my profession I learned that my little ol' Associate degree in machine design wasn't going to do.

Guess what I found when I looked at the schools. (this was in the mid to late 1980's)
Almost nothing!! After more searching I came upon the ASQ. Finally a place where you could get credit for your knowledge, not how many credit hours you have. I jumped at the chance. Got my CQT, CQA, and CQE.

Most of these certs' require recertification every three years. Which requires proof of continuing education, or retesting. Most require a certain minimum time in the profession before taking the exam. Certification means that you are willing to take the time, and effort to learn your profession and continue learning.

I realize that more schools are offering quality as a field of study, but how many, and how magnanimous are they when it comes to cost? Didn't most of us learn our trade in the trenches?

In sum, YES certifications have been of benefit to me. And I don't believe them to be simply a revenue generator for ASQ.

I now step off my soap box.


Low tech is better than no tech.

[This message has been edited by JRKH (edited 20 August 2001).]

IP: Logged

Al Dyer
Forum Wizard

Posts: 814
From:Lapeer, MI USA
Registered: Oct 2000

posted 20 August 2001 02:22 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Al Dyer   Click Here to Email Al Dyer     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I don't believe the tests themselves to be total money generators (although I have a different stand on the "refresher courses"), there is a purpose.

As for the CEU credits, wouldn't a sane quality proffesional realize that continuing education is in their own benefit, whether ASQ certified or not?

This is not ASQ bashing on my part, just a view of my experiences, just like yours.

Have a good day.


IP: Logged

Forum Contributor

Posts: 36
From:Cincinnati, Ohio
Registered: Apr 2001

posted 20 August 2001 04:58 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for JRKH     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
You are absolutely correct. Continuing education should be a part of any profession. My point was simply that ASQ doesn't simply hand out certs.

As with anything else, it depends on what you do with it. If your serious about your profession it will show. I just think ASQ certs' are one way to do that.

No bashing on my part either. JMHO.


Low tech is better than no tech.

IP: Logged

Rick Goodson
Forum Wizard

Posts: 135
From:Wuakesha, Wisconsin, USA
Registered: Aug 2000

posted 20 August 2001 05:45 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Rick Goodson   Click Here to Email Rick Goodson     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I am not sure whether there is a value to having my ASQ certifications. Certainly the recertification forces a behavior of continuing education or other activies to 'stay current' in my chosen profession. Would I go to seminars and classes if they were not required. Sure, but probably not as often as I should.

On the other hand, my IRCA certification required that I 'prove' I have some expertise by having a log of the audits I performed. These logs are 'signed off' by the people I audit, most of which hire me because they feel I have that expertise but for the most part are not capable of making that assessment. Maybe the answer lies some where in between. I keep all of my certifications current because some customers value the ASQ certifications, some value the IRCA registration, and some value both.

IP: Logged

Forum Contributor

Posts: 42
From:Princeton, IN, USA
Registered: Feb 2001

posted 20 August 2001 07:18 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for AJLenarz   Click Here to Email AJLenarz     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Just because one has attended a hand gun safety class and has received a certification doesn’t mean they won’t shoot themselves in the foot.

Just because one has a B.S. in business doesn’t mean they will be successful in running company.

Just because one has achieved a CQM certification, doesn’t guarantee they will be successful in managing a quality department.

But there is a level of confidence and respect that goes behind the training and certification, but no fool proof guarantee.

Originally posted by JRKH:
As with anything else, it depends on what you do with it.

I believe there is a differentiation between knowledge and wisdom. Knowledge is the sum that one has learned, wisdom is how they choose to apply it. Or in the words of JRKH.... "it depends on what you do with it".

IP: Logged

Forum Contributor

Posts: 58
From:Lilburn, GA, USA
Registered: Sep 2000

posted 22 August 2001 11:53 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Graeme   Click Here to Email Graeme     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Here are a few points that have not been addressed here yet.

1. You must do more than just pay the fee and pass the test to obtain an ASQ certification. In order to be eligible you must already have a number of years of work experience in the applicable body of knowledge. Some - but not all - of the experience may be substituted with academic work. You must also have two people attest that you are a qualified practitioner in the body of knowledge, and provide proof of professionalism such as membership in a professional society that is a member of ABET. (You do not have to be a member of ASQ.)

2. They are NOT easy exams to pass! I have not been involved in proctoring them for several years so I don't have current data, but the first-time pass rate is surprisingly low. The CQT and CQE exams are by far the toughest I have taken during my career, and I did them by choice. I know several people who have taken them as many as four times in attempts to pass.

3. All but two of ASQ's certifications require regular RE-certification. That involves documenting and providing objective evidence of your ongoing employment, continuing education, publishing (darn - The Cove does'nt count!), teaching, professional development and more. If you don't accumulate enough points then you must take the exam again - and I have yet to meet anyone who wants to do that!

4. Some of these certifications are not exactly new - others are at the leading edge. The ASQ Certified Quality Engineer program started in 1968. Some are much less popular than others (anybody here a CMI or CRE?). There are new ones coming on line because of popular demand. In the ten years I have been a member the number of available certifications has doubled, and I know of at least one more that is being developed.

I am very glad I have my certifications and they are a big benefit to me. First, they validate my knowledge, skills and experience to me. Second, they do the same for an employer. (I regularly see placement listings that say something like "BSEE and 5 years experience, or an ASQ CQE".)

As JRKH alluded to, professional certification is a way of validating that you have real experience in the trenches and have learned something from it, instead of only having credit hours piled higher and deeper. But certification by itself, like a degree by itself, cannot be the whole answer especially in a job search. You still have to sell yourself as a total package and not just wave paper in their face.

Graeme C. Payne
ASQ Certified Quality Engineer

[This message has been edited by Graeme (edited 22 August 2001).]

IP: Logged

All times are Eastern Standard Time (USA)

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Marc Smith | The Elsmar Cove Home Page

Please Visit the new Elsmar Cove Forums! All these threads are there and much more!

Main Site Search
Y'All Come Back Now, Ya Hear?
Powered by FreeBSD!Made With A Mac!Powered by Apache!