Welcome to what was The Original Cayman Cove Forums! This thread is carried over and continued in the Current Elsmar Cove Forums

This is a "Frozen" Legacy Forum.
Discussions since 2001 are HERE

 The New Elsmar Cove Forums The New Elsmar Cove Forums   Measurement, Test and Calibration   Starting to Calculate Uncertainties    profile | register | preferences | faq | search
 Author Topic:   Starting to Calculate Uncertainties Debbieunregistered posted 04 June 2001 01:17 PM               I am starting to plan to calculate uncertainties for a calibration lab. I've seen many approaches taken, i.e., experiments to determine random variation, analyses of the history of calibration and an approach that involves taking the partial derivative with respect to the various parameters that influence the result. My first uncertainty calculation is pressure drop which of coarse is related to air flow, diameter of the tube, temperature etc. Would the partial derivative approach alone be OK -- or do I have to run an experiment in addition to performing the calculation. Also, am I right to assume that once I determine all the uncertainties using the partial derivative approach, that I also consider the uncertainty of the standard that I'm using?I'm desperate and confused-- so please help.DebbieIP: Logged GraemeForum Contributor Posts: 30From:Lilburn, GA, USARegistered: Sep 2000 posted 06 June 2001 09:06 AM                Debbie,I would like to suggest some things as an action plan. You probably have already done some of this, but just in case ...Research and Study: Get a copy of ANSI/NCSL Z540-2, the US version of the ISO Guide to the Expression of Uncertainty in Measurement. Get a good reference book on measurement uncertainty or error analysis. Search the Cove Forums for earlier message threads on this topic. A couple of suggestions are https://elsmar.com/ubb/Forum4/HTML/000047.html and https://elsmar.com/ubb/Forum4/HTML/000217.html Look at the tutorial on Measurement Systems Analysis on this forum. (https://elsmar.com/level2/cal_q1.html) Look at the NIST reference, http://physics.nist.gov/cuu/index.html Arm yourself with Tools:In particular, look at the FREEware measurement uncertainty calculator by Chris Grachanen. you can download it from Cal Lab Magazine, http://www.callabmag.com/freeware.html Apply the Principles, but Start Simple: Get the low hanging fruit first. Start with what you already know or can easily find out, and get that documented first. (Example: the accuracy specifications of your measuring instruments.) I often continue with a simple sensitivity analysis of the major paramters that I can measure or control. (For example, if a measuring instrument's uncertainty changes by 5 ppm per degree C, calculate it out at a few measurement points to see how much effect it has.) Along the way, document your processes for determining various factors. Make sure you have every uncertainty factor properly characterized as Type A or Type B. Type A is factors that you measure yourself and analyze statistically. (Example: hourly values from your temperature/humidity datalogger.) Type B is numbers you get from other sources. (Example: the accuracy specification of your anemometer.) Before going to the work of setting up a designed experiment run, ask yourself if the factor is really a significant contributor to your measurement result, to the point where it makes economic sense to reduce it. If it is a significant portion and you think you can economically reduce the variation, then DOE may be justified. If the amount of variation is a trivial part of the result it may not be worth the effort. Does this help some?------------------Graeme C. PayneASQ Certified Quality Engineer ASQ_Graeme@yahoo.com [This message has been edited by Graeme (edited 06 June 2001).]IP: Logged
 All times are Eastern Standard Time (USA) next newest topic | next oldest topic Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic Hop to: Select a Forum or Archive List of Forums: Category: General Quality Topics --------------------Measurement, Test and CalibrationStatistical Techniques and 6 SigmaDocumentationNonconformance and Corrective Action SystemsContinuous ImprovementBenchmarkingTPM - Total Productive MaintenanceBaldrige National Quality AwardTQM - Total Quality ManagementMiscellaneous Quality TopicsBook ReviewsQuality Assurance SoftwareOccupations in Quality Assurance Category: National & International Standards --------------------ISO 9001/4:2000ISO 9000:1994ISO 14001 And Other Environmental SpecsGeneral ISO TopicsBS8800 & OHSAS 18001FDA and Medical DevicesAS 9100TL 9000 Category: Auditing and Registrars --------------------AuditingRegistrars and Registration Category: Automotive Related --------------------TS 16949QS-9000Tooling and Equipment SuppliersForo en Espa–olAPQP and PPAPFMEA and Control PlansEmbedded Devices and Control SoftwareVDA Volumes Including 6.1 Category: Guide Buyers Forums --------------------Guide Pre-Purchase QuestionsGuide Post-Purchase Questions Category: Software Quality Assurance --------------------Linux InfoTickit Scheme ForumSoftware Quality AssuranceInternet History Category: Odds and Ends --------------------Used - Buy and SellForums - How Do They Work? Suggestions!Company Advertisements - Free Offers, etc. List of Archives: PoliticsJokes