A
axelrios
Hello,
My first post here, been reading for a while,
A supplier sent a component with solder on a specific side that the drawing do not call for solder, the drawing call for this side for plating on this side.The part cant be used like this, it is not only a cosmetic issue, this cause shorts and damages our tools
The thing is that on the other side that should be solder as stated on the drawing, per unknow reason some solder move to the other face of the parts( a lot)
The supplier says two things:
1. It is a design problem because they cannot avoid the solder on this side with current design, although we had no issues for like 5 years in a row.
2. The supplier says that the drawing do not mention that there should not be solder, so technically they can put solder if the want, my logic says that the drawing cannot mention all exclusion for foreign material on an area, by the supplier logic they can put plastic or even peanut butter jelly if they want.
Is there a norm, o specification on the media that, help defend my case?
What is your opinion on this case?
My first post here, been reading for a while,
A supplier sent a component with solder on a specific side that the drawing do not call for solder, the drawing call for this side for plating on this side.The part cant be used like this, it is not only a cosmetic issue, this cause shorts and damages our tools
The thing is that on the other side that should be solder as stated on the drawing, per unknow reason some solder move to the other face of the parts( a lot)
The supplier says two things:
1. It is a design problem because they cannot avoid the solder on this side with current design, although we had no issues for like 5 years in a row.
2. The supplier says that the drawing do not mention that there should not be solder, so technically they can put solder if the want, my logic says that the drawing cannot mention all exclusion for foreign material on an area, by the supplier logic they can put plastic or even peanut butter jelly if they want.
Is there a norm, o specification on the media that, help defend my case?
What is your opinion on this case?